I think it's safe to say Gator fans' opinions vary... I've only been watching UF games for a little over 40 years, so I'm not the ultimate judge.
That said, the GSU loss didn't bother me that much because GSU is a 6-time DI-AA national champion, and was actually in their transition year to DI last season. They accepted an invitation to the Sun Belt in March of last year, making the loss to them not all that different from Bama's loss to Sun Belt team ULM in 2007. And, of course, Michigan lost to App. State, who still isn't DI, in 2007, and they're the winningest program in NCAA history.
I also like Muschamp and hope he stays a very long time. Having seen more than my share of UF coaches and years of substandard ball, I'm not impatient and know it often takes a few years to straighten out a program left in a shambles... takes even longer when the guy charged with fixing it is a rookie coach in his first hc job. The vast majority of boosters our family associates with agree.
Last season's record doesn't really bother me either; UF had the 2nd longest streak in the country of programs without a losing season leading up to last year... 33 years without a losing season is a boast few teams' fans can make or enjoy.
UF would NEVER consider hiring Petrino. NEVER. Too many of our Bulls and Foley lived through 1984-'85; no way we take a chance on a guy who has already proven he lacks character. Franklin is turning out to be somebody we'd avoid too; in fact PSU is wishing their athletic department had done a better job of vetting candidates right about now.
UF still had the SEC's 2nd best defense last year despite the offense keeping them on the field much longer than they should have been in every single game. If Roper improves the offense even a little, so that drives are sustained, we'll be fine. Looking forward to it.