I normally agree, but pff is a good compliment to the eye test. The eye test shows that he was so ineffective he was benched at least three times during the season and got moved to guard because he was so bad at tackle.
I agree he wasn’t great- but from what I saw of A&M games it wasn’t anything more than a freshman playing before he was ready.
with positions like OL it’s impossible to know who’s mistake it was, grading some a 25 makes it seem like they are irredeemable trash.