207 others
Wild and Wonderful
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2020
- Messages
- 1,555
- Likes
- 1,843
Maybe it boils down to Scots Irish ancestry being the framework of Appalachia, and i dunno... the Appalachian mountains?? more than saying German people, which is 90% of Ohio, who generally lived in towns as merchants and shopkeepers within Appalachia but were not the same. robbed of resources isn't the same culture. Robbed of resources would make Africa Appalachian and Alaska. Appalachia wasn't necessarily famous for Polka music and the accordian as seen in Texas and Ohio. I've never ate sauerkraut in Appalachia but have in Ohio. Even Pennsylvanian Appalachia was scots Irish before that claim is made. Ohio will never be Appalachian just because there are some rural people who do meth there and pretend to be rednecks is not appalachian culture. Mexico is not the USA because the Rio Grande river separates them, and Mexico shares a lot of similarities as across the river in El Paso, same with Ohio, the Ohio River is the end of the region and always will be. Ohio needs to make it's own culture it is not our job to be inclusive of youI was born in Harlan, Kentucky. I’ve lived in Mountain City, Trade, Johnson City, and Gray Tennessee. Also lived in Morristown, Flushing(Belmont County) and Athens Ohio. I now live in Armstrong County, PA after a short stent in Allegheny County (Pittsburgh).
All of those areas happen to fall under the commission. They are different in many ways, yes. Heritage, history, culture, heck they were on opposite sides of a bloody war. The thing that unites them, though, is that they have sat on natural resources through the centuries and been exploited for them. They have in many cases been taken advantage of. Whether it was timber, coal, iron, natural gas, etc… people not residing in these places have enriched themselves beyond comprehension on the backs and on the land of these people. This has happened over and over. There was such a great need identified for the people in these areas that became depressed after whatever resource is taken from the lands, they needed an advocate. Hence, the only joint Federal/State combined commission of its kind was created to define and hopefully uplift the region.
I’m not sure what your definition of Appalachia is. Seems based largely on elevation, and if so, then ok… but I can definitively say people in rural Ohio and Pennsylvania have more in common with people in rural East Tennessee than they are dissimilar.
According to your definition of Appalachia culture being defined as what happened to them, Irish Italians and Jews are the same. Mississippi is Appalachian to you because you're an ARC shill anyways I have no need to argue against crap. Appalachia is named after the Appalachian mountains and the range continues into Scotland not Germany. You would likely argue California is an Atlantic state because they're defined as ACC by a commission, and the wine industry is in decline by foreign investment exploitation in California and Virginia. Coal mining and resources is not what defines Appalachia. West NC is major Appalachia for example. Ohio is not in the top 15 states for historical origins of bluegrass, just to begin the argument of culture. They're not in the top 20 for moonshine historical origins. Ironically the top 7 is just Appalachia
A lot of appalachians did move to Ohio maybe that is why you are confused. A lot of Californians moved to Tennessee but I'll be damned before twisting logic.
Last edited: