Who’s better, Milton or Milroe?

[SaintLouisVol]

Those hitches are immediate throws, not part of progressions. You throw those cause that is the play called.

I agree with you, but it does beg the question of why so many of those calls are made? I'm not sure they want JM working through the progressions.

 

[Spawn]

Are we really asking this after watching Milton disappear in the most important games? 7 point, then 10 points and 7 of the 10 was The RB.

Everyone over Milton

 

[Mtnvol80]

Omg. It took me a second to realize when this post was made. I thought, is this a serious question? It's funny looking back at how many people said Milton. They were very wrong. In Milton's defense, Milroe has a huge advantage of being coached by a vastly superior coach.

Are you saying Rees is better than CJH at QB development? Saban doesn't work with QBs to my knowledge

 

[utchs81]

Fun to look back and ponder how some of these threads have aged.

 

[secking]

Milroe is the better runner and has a very strong arm, but his interceptions are killers.

Milton has a cannon as we all know, but is back to struggling with with consistency, yet he’s still not throwing to the other team.

For me, I’m picking Milton.

Who has been developed better this year?

The ND OC has surprised me this year.

 

[BigD]

In my opinion, there is not a QB in college football in its entirety that is worse than Milton. He's bad at everything. He can throw 1000 miles away sure but until we get a basketball player at 7' to play WR no one's catching his passes.

 

[Orangeslice13]

Are we really asking this after watching Milton disappear in the most important games? 7 point, then 10 points and 7 of the 10 was The RB.

Everyone over Milton

Not me.
I love the guy.
He’s been a great teammate and a Vol to be proud of.

Unfortunately he wasn’t the best Player ever. I really wish a guy like that had been able to put it together but it just didn’t happen. But I’m definitely not over him.

 

[Spawn]

Not me.
I love the guy.
He’s been a great teammate and a Vol to be proud of.

Unfortunately he wasn’t the best Player ever. I really wish a guy like that had been able to put it together but it just didn’t happen. But I’m definitely not over him.

The question was who would you take. I like Milton. I think he can be developed, unfortunately, their were a lot of expectation based on the win over Clemson and he has been up and down.

 

[Orangeslice13]

The question was who would you take. I like Milton. I think he can be developed, unfortunately, their were a lot of expectation based on the win over Clemson and he has been up and down.

I think the guy needs a sports psychologist. He’s clearly got all the tools but just can’t seem to put it together.

 

[laroc99a]

Milton should be on a baseball diamond not a football field. Hell maybe he just needs some glasses to be more accurate I don’t know but that arm in right field would be nice.

 

[Chitlin&theDude]

Are you saying Rees is better than CJH at QB development? Saban doesn't work with QBs to my knowledge

Saban micromanages everything at that program. He deserves the credit.

 

[SockeyeVol]

This thread is exhibit 1A of why overconfident statements that say there's no room for discussion.....should just be ignored.

 

[DaddyChad]

He was surrounded by the same 5 stars earlier in the season when he sucked. He improved significantly. No one develops talent like Saban. Watch the NFL

Yes bc Saban is a qb guru….

 

[OptimisticFan]

Fun to look back and ponder how some of these threads have aged.

Pre-season hype is one helluva drug!

 

[Orangeslice13]

Saban micromanages everything at that program. He deserves the credit.

And the judgment for the 2 rapist and the guy who hits girls after games, still on the team and unpunished.


I would not piss on Nick Saban if he was on fire. I would roast marshmallows though