James Cheek is one of the faces of the University of Tennessee. He should comport himself with dignity when he is before the public and in front of the camera. I expect the behavior he displayed in front of a national audience from a toddler. I don't expect it from the leader of my Alma mater.
Those who believe Alabama, LSU, Florida, and the other SEC programs hold their student-athletes to the same admission standards they place upon the rest of the student body are absolutely kidding themselves. You can't demand Doug Atkins and Reggie White on Saturday if you're only allowing Poindexter and Percy into class Monday through Friday. There just aren't enough Charles Davis and Peyton Manning-types in the nation's best academic high schools allowing you to compete against programs casting a wider net for talent.
The presence of Bobby Dodd and George Cafego on our campus didn't hurt Tennessee's reputation as a university in the 1920s and 1930s. Shazzon Bradley and Leonard Little didn't harm our academic ranking one iota in the 1980s and 1990s. The restrictions placed upon athletics by Cheek and his minions haven't done one thing to enhance the prestige of the University of Tennessee as an academic institution. It has only served to put us in the bottom-tier of athletics programs in terms of performance in our conference.
We can have quality academics and athletics. But you are not going to have quality athletics in the SEC with the existence of a climate overly-restrictive in admissions and completely hostile towards sports on campus. This is the climate Chancellor Cheek has created at Tennessee. The result? Too close to Sewanee and Tulane for comfort.
I have yet to see one of Cheek's defenders demonstrate to us how a level playing field for student-athlete admissions would pose harm either to the academic mission of the University of Tennessee or to their particular degree.