Obviously this is an exciting question and one we can focus on relentlessly as the days tick down toward Aug 31st.
It seems to me that the vibe coming from the staff gives Worley the edge at the moment with the caveat that it's really wide open. So I'm going with it's really wide open but Worley has the edge.
Now I think they are all 4 smart - and I suspect more mature than Bray. I don't think anyone has said any of the 4 have Bray's arm talents but we could gather up some beer bottles, head up to balcony and have some evaluation drills. We'll need someone to put the videos on YouTube so all the analysts have access.
Seriously, we may not know even after fall camp. Sometime a great practice player is a lousy game player and vice versa and I think most every coach knows this. I think all the guys as has been said are doing everything they have been asked to do.
In reviewing past CBJ stats I didn't see many long pass plays at all, "most definitely" not what we were used to with Bray. I think these guys are looking for the best fit to run our "new" offense. On the other hand it's been said repeatedly that we'll fit our schemes to our talent on the field.
Experience does count, maturity too if you have it. Knowing the offense is important. athleticism, ability, instincts, leadership, and all that matter as well but in the end it's about producing on the field. It begins with practice and then has to be followed by translating that production to the game. We could have 2 starters ready for game 1 but I think CBJ wants to name a single starter. It could be a tough call but I think he'll do that just to get rid of the distraction. Meanwhile the other guy will be ready should the opportunity, for whatever reason, present itself.
Do I think Justin is ready? I don't know. Nate? Don't know. One of the Freshmen? Sorry, don't know. I think it looks like Justin has the edge going into fall camp but it's really wide open.