Here is what I posted last night.
Whoever said yes first out of Latrell Scott, Tony Ball, Casey Woods, Thomas "TD Woods", Troy Walters and Darin Hinshaw.
I would have rather had a "minority" coach that had spent his career recruiting in the south. I think Azzanni is a very good coach but I just think we needed a better recruiter with this hire.
GL, I agree with you that my ideal candidate would be a minority with southern recruiting ties. Specifically, Florida and/or Georgia. A "splash" hire would have helped for this recruiting cycle but a good overall recruiter and developer of talent will prove more beneficial in the long run.
What I don't understand is your list above. I think Azzanni is a take over all but, arguably, two of them using your criteria.
Latrell Scott has bounced around about as much as Azzanni. Rivals shows him as landing only 2 recruits, 1-4 star and 1-3 star and it shows he landed none while at Florida. His recruiting time has been spent mostly in the Virginia area, not Florida or Georgia. The killer for me is the baggage. Was fired for not one but two DUIs while at Richmond. Too high a risk for CBJ in my opinion.
Casey Woods and Troy Walters don't have anywhere near the coaching resume as Azzanni. Woods one year as grad assistant at UT and 3 years in "Quality Control". Walters was a great player but has been coaching only 4 years (at three separate stops). Neither has been credited by Rivals as landing any recruit, of any rating, at any school, ever. Advantage...Azzanni.
Thomas Woods has lots of years coaching the position including 5 at Tulane, 1 at Jacksonville State, 5 at Mississippi. He has spent his career in the south. His Rivals profile lists 1-3 star and 5-2 star recruits. None from Florida. Wouldn't think this is what you meant by great recruiter.
The two that stand-up are Tony Ball and Hinshaw. Both have spent a number of years with major programs in the south and have shown stability.
Ball compares favorably to Azzanni per Rivals though not decisively (2-4 stars, 2-3 stars vs Azzanni's 1 and 1). He is a minority. Hinshaw, per Rivals is by far the best recruiter with 5-4 star recruits and 3-3 star recruits. As I mentioned in a prior post, I wasn't impressed by the job he did with our receivers this year and and he, of course, isn't a minority.
I am fine with Azzanni. Tee's name and story helped eclipse his limited resume in my opinion. Hinshaw's recruiting helps offset what I feel are coaching deficiencies. Would have been fine with Ball or the Florida State guy as well.