Paul could be a nobody. Dawson could be a bust. Johnson could be the next Askew.
I would rather take the risk with a scholarship with Paul and potentially immediately upgrade our LB corps than do nothing and miss out.
I can't see that logic. If they are fairly sure he won't contribute then they will miss out twice by taking him- once when he doesn't play and twice when he ties up a scholarship that could be given to someone much better. Even if it isn't a position of need, I would rather take someone else who would contribute.