You have to build the best class you can, and that isn't based off of stars. The first thing any class has to address is needs. You have to fill your positions of need. If you don't, having the number one class in the nation wouldn't mean squat if you don't have every position covered. So I understand when a cut needed to be made, DE was the position we could most afford to lose a recruit at. It's absolutely part of recruiting, but it's a very dirty part of recruiting.
Here's the rub to me. The staff sold this kid on UT and he fell hard. Everything suggests he was absolutely in love with UT. A big part of Butch's sales pitch is the "brick by brick" family foundation he wants to establish here. There's no way Butch and staff went into this recruiting cycle not knowing their needs. So why pull in commits just to pull in commits when you know there are still need positions and those promised schollies are going to be needed elsewhere? At the very least, you make the schollies conditional, and nothing in any of Ford's comments has suggested he thought his scholly was conditional. You can tell by his comments he thought it was firm. And he bought into UT heart and soul. Kid probably feels like he was just left at the altar. And for more Vol fans not to be able to empathize with that surprises me considering we've been left at that altar by a recruit on more than one occassion. This shiz works both ways. If KMac suddenly decommitted tomorrow, I'd be mad as hell. My words wouldn't be nice. So I'm not going to defend us doing the exact same thing to a recruit. It sucks, and like it or not, intentional or not, Butch screwed this kid over.
I'll go back to what I said earlier. I understand this shiz happens, and it's ugly, but let's call it ugly and not try to dismiss it as "everyone does it". That doesn't magically make it right. I'm not screaming for heads to fly, I'm simply saying maybe the coaches need to reevaluate how they accept commits from these kids. Especially their approach of "if you commit to us we really don't want you taking other visits." Without looking it up, did Ford take any other visits? Did he have the chance to form relationships with other coaches as a back up plan? Butch is a damn good recruiter. I won't take that away from him in the least. But if he's gonna demand loyalty, he needs to return that loyalty. Sure, Ford will land somewhere, but he had built up this dream of playing for UT. He was told he was going to get to live that dream. Now, two weeks before NSD, that dream was ripped from him. Butch did that. I understand the whys, but it still doesn't make it right or excusable.