Catbone
Hit me baby one more time
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2010
- Messages
- 67,188
- Likes
- 65,030
He can't cut. No need to rush him... We also have some pretty good players ahead him already... Why waste a year for a few plays a game at the end of the year... ?How come? You only redshirt a guy if he isn't ready to play. Either from injury or undeveloped skills. I think we can all agree Preston is skilled enough to play as a true freshmen. The only question left is health. As of right now, there is no reason to believe he won't be ready to contribute at least by the tail end of the season.
Why would you hold out an elite talent that is ready to go in October/November? A redshirt does nothing for guys like Preston Wiliams. He's projected to be a high caliber player. Those guys don't hang around for 5 years. At best you're hoping he stays 4. If he's only gonna be here 4 years, might as well play him all 4.
Also if he can contibute and help us win, why would you not want him out there. Every win is critical right now for a program like ours that needs to show we're moving in the right direction to keep attracting elite recruits.
He can't cut. No need to rush him... We also have some pretty good players ahead him already... Why waste a year for a few plays a game at the end of the year... ?
IF...Right now. However, no one said that would be the case all season. If he's cleared by the doctors in October, why would you still hold him out? Remember he got hurt last November. ACL injuries usually keep an athlete out 9 months. We'd be hitting 10 months since the surgery in September.
He can't cut. No need to rush him... We also have some pretty good players ahead him already... Why waste a year for a few plays a game at the end of the year... ?
Idc about a fifth year... I just think he needs to be brought back slower then most of you.. JMO.. I also have tempered expeditions of him early on though, coming back from injury..
He can't cut. No need to rush him... We also have some pretty good players ahead him already... Why waste a year for a few plays a game at the end of the year... ?
I think this is where the confusion continues to come from.... No one is saying play him if he can't cut or isn't 100% or to rush him back...... He should be fine at some point in the season. At that point you play him because you lose nothing. He will not be here 5 years anyway.
He can't cut. No need to rush him... We also have some pretty good players ahead him already... Why waste a year for a few plays a game at the end of the year... ?
I hear ya. Testament to ol Stones Jones for locking down talent in state..can't wait to see what he can do.I'm really glad he chose to go to spot where he could play and help the team. As for my "QB" posts, VN always said as soon as he signed Butch would move him to Safety. He was adamant that he was a QB. He didn't give schools a look that weren't recruiting him at another position. Alabama came after him hard. 3 schools said he was a QB... UT, OSU, and Auburn.
I'm thrilled he's a WR but if we hadn't recruited a "QB" he'd be in Auburn right now
So he can't cut or their not letting him cut yet?
Serious question, because there is a big difference....