'15 VA DT Tim Settle

#827
#827
Here's my order for best coach in my mind.

1) Stripling
2) Martinez
3) Mahoney
4) Thigpen
5) Gillespie
6) Bajakian
7) Elder
8) Jancek
9) Azzani
 
#828
#828
Bowling green- From reading back it seems they had strong WR corps all 4 yrs he was there. He also coached Freddie Barnes (NCAA record holder) as a freshman (obviously doesn't mean it was all due to Z).

CMU-Coached Antonio Brown (NFL), Kito Poblah (CFL)

Wisconsin- coached Jared abberderis during a season where he had 78 catches ( CAREER HIGH, NOT DOWN FROM THE YR BEFORE), 1081 yds (CAREER HIGH), and 7 TDs
 
#830
#830
Burger said:
Here's my order for best coach in my mind.

1) Stripling
2) Martinez
3) Mahoney
4) Thigpen
5) Gillespie
6) Bajakian
7) Elder
8) Jancek
9) Azzani
Click to expand...

1) Azzani
2) Stripling
3) Gillespie (he got Neal to stop dancing in the backfield)
4) Thigpen
5a) Mahoney
5b) Martinez
6) Elder
7a) Bajakian
7b) Jancek
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#831
#831
Vol865 said:
Bowling green- From reading back it seems they had strong WR corps all 4 yrs he was there. He also coached Freddie Barnes (NCAA record holder) as a freshman (obviously doesn't mean it was all due to Z).

CMU-Coached Antonio Brown (NFL), Kito Poblah (CFL)

Wisconsin- coached Jared abberderis during a season where he had 78 catches ( CAREER HIGH, NOT DOWN FROM THE YR BEFORE), 1081 yds (CAREER HIGH), and 7 TDs
Click to expand...

No.

Z was with Abberderis in 2012, only 49 catches for 837 yards, down from the year before and the year after in catches and yards.

Antonio Brown is the highlight of his resume, and it's a good highlight.
 
#832
#832
jave36 said:
No.

Z was with Abberderis in 2012, only 49 catches for 837 yards, down from the year before and the year after in catches and yards.

Antonio Brown is the highlight of his resume, and it's a good highlight.
Click to expand...

You are correct. I was looking at it wrong. I still believe he is one of the best at teaching the fundamentals and the small stuff at WR
 
#833
#833
Vol865 said:
You are correct. I was looking at it wrong. I still believe he is one of the best at teaching the fundamentals and the small stuff at WR
Click to expand...

I have no problem with Z, he may turn out fine. Strip has proven many times though that he can develop pro players.
 
#834
#834
jave36 said:
I have no problem with Z, he may turn out fine. Strip has proven many times though that he can develop pro players.
Click to expand...

Strip is like 40 something and and azzani might be 30, though.


Thats like saying, Dale Earnhardt was better than Jimmy Johnson because Earnhardt had already proven himself even though Johnson was like 10.


I really dont care about NASCAR. Just using it for arguments sake.
 
#835
#835
Vol865 said:
Strip is like 40 something and and azzani might be 30, though.


Thats like saying, Dale Earnhardt was better than Jimmy Johnson because Earnhardt had already proven himself even though Johnson was like 10.


I really dont care about NASCAR. Just using it for arguments sake.
Click to expand...

Once Z wins multiple national titles like JJ, you can say that :) No one thought JJ was better than Earnhardt when he first came on the scene. No one could have, it would have just been unfounded guessing. There's always a chance that an up and Comer will turn out better than a proven winner like Strip. But to say he is already better than the proven winner is unfounded opinion.
 
#837
#837
Vol865 said:
1) Azzani
2) Stripling
3) Gillespie (he got Neal to stop dancing in the backfield)
4) Thigpen
5a) Mahoney
5b) Martinez
6) Elder
7a) Bajakian
7b) Jancek
Click to expand...

I think you have Martinez way too low. I have Strip and Willie 1a and 1b, Gillespie, Thig, and then flip a coin for the rest of the order.
 
#845
#845
jave36 said:
If you aren't using NFL players and continuity with the same coach as criteria, what is your criteria?
Click to expand...

The honest answer is I have none, because I don't believe it's possible to judge.

You don't "coach" a kid into the NFL. NFL players are born.
 
#848
#848
Vol8188 said:
The honest answer is I have none, because I don't believe it's possible to judge.

You don't "coach" a kid into the NFL. NFL players are born.
Click to expand...

NFL players are made. Khalil Mack proves that among with other three stars. Derek Dooley would of been decent here if that was true.
 
#850
#850
Burger said:
NFL players are made. Khalil Mack proves that among with other three stars. Derek Dooley would of been decent here if that was true.
Click to expand...

So CBJ makes these kids 6'3 330? Becoming a pro athlete is all about genetics. Very little coaching involved.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top