pmc...trust me when i say this..
anyone was better then randy..he isnt that good at all
My wife is a Cane. As a result, I saw every painful snap of the Randy Shannon era. Believe me, I'm no fan of Randy when it comes to game plan, X's and O's, etc. In fact, while I love what I see from Bray, it's hard to argue that CDD's game plan (air raid!) is really any different than Randy's was with Jacory. With that said, Randy devoted his entire life to Miami, had Miami out of the headlines for the first time in years when it comes to off field incidents, was through the roof in terms of graduation rates, and won at Miami. The problem, of course, was that he didn't win enough.
So great, fire him. But know what you want -- and that's the problem with Miami right now.
They are having an identity crisis. You've got a bunch of still relevant NFL legends/alumni who expect Miami to regain its swagger, which is probably unreasonable given Miami's facilities, the fact that it's a private school, and Luther Campbell presumably is not still lining the player's pockets. Conversely, you've got a Miami administration under Donna Sh. that is really only concerned about the graduation rates and modest winnings.
So, if you fire Shannon, because you want to regain the swagger, have you made a good step in that direction by hiring Al Golden? Does Al Golden bring a sense of swagger? Does he bring the recruiting buzz that will encourage the local talent to forgo playing at UF or for Jimbo Fisher? Does anything about his hiring scream big time? I just don't think so. Only time will tell.