I'd like to try their 10 year old rye. It's supposed to be very good, but it's pricey. I've just had their standard single barrel rye. If you like rye you might not care for it as much as some others because I don't think it's as bold (not aged as long as the 10year). I like it because it's a little sweeter than some ryes. But I think there are better ones for the money.
I wasn't familiar with their history so I looked them up. It looks like a similar situation to Pappy. Made great whiskey, went out of business, another distiller bought the name. Same name, different whiskey. Made by the same people who distill Willett, Noah's Mill, Rowan's Creek.