jdogvol
Retired from PA. Finally back in TN.
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2009
- Messages
- 2,006
- Likes
- 2,767
Cmon, this is classic āDidnāt want him anywayā when a recruit goes elsewhere. Every summer report is glowing about every player until they leave, then suddenly we find out theyāre struggling.
I donāt know how he, or anyone else, was doing. Everybody agrees to take the offseason reports with a grain of salt, I take them with a boulder of saltSo you think he was doing well and his perceived playing time was not a factor in his decision to leave in the short time he was here? Not to even mention that StoernerFumbles has consistently proven to have real insider info.
So you think he was doing well and his perceived playing time was not a factor in his decision to leave in the short time he was here? Not to even mention that StoernerFumbles has consistently proven to have real insider info.
Missing all but 2 summer practices would definitely put him behind in learning our systems (and probably conditioning etc as well). No fault of his that he got hurt, but thatās a possible explanation for why he might have been falling behind and looking at losing out on PT early in the year.How many summer practices did he participate in--two? Nobody can make a decision about how much playing time he might get after a couple of summer practices/scrimmages. There were probably multiple reasons for his decision.
Itās my understanding that the players spend a bunch of time in the gym with each other outside of the allowed organized practices. Iād guess itās not too difficult to determine where you stack up against the competition before Barnes blows the whistle. JMOHow many summer practices did he participate in--two? Nobody can make a decision about how much playing time he might get after a couple of summer practices/scrimmages. There were probably multiple reasons for his decision.
You're sure? The Kentucky game must have been the only one you watched
I believe he was plenty "good". He found out this might not be the best place for him to play extended minutes and be a "go to" guy. We're sort of loaded with talent. I doubt the cultural difference was much of a factor. After practicing with the group a couple of times, he realized this might not be the place to shine. It's likely that's the case. This MIGHT be Barnes' most talented roster since he's been here.What I'm saying is just because a player plays for Harvard it doesn't mean they are beneath the players in the SEC. It's the whole 3 star thing in football. Not every 5 star ends up being a 5 star, and not every 3 star never reaches a 5 star level. I don't know much about Ledlum's game but because he transferred out we don't have to pull the "we didn't want him anyway" and act like he probably wasn't that good because of the league he came from.
I think the pushback is against the idea that because he averaged 18 at Harvard that he would have similar production here. The SEC is a tougher league and better competition. Itās not guaranteed that he would have even averaged half. Thatās not to say that heās not good, just that he probably wasnāt going to be all sec good or even so good that heās irreplaceable. Given our roster, he very well could have been on track for only 10-15 mpgWhat I'm saying is just because a player plays for Harvard it doesn't mean they are beneath the players in the SEC. It's the whole 3 star thing in football. Not every 5 star ends up being a 5 star, and not every 3 star never reaches a 5 star level. I don't know much about Ledlum's game but because he transferred out we don't have to pull the "we didn't want him anyway" and act like he probably wasn't that good because of the league he came from.
What I'm saying is just because a player plays for Harvard it doesn't mean they are beneath the players in the SEC. It's the whole 3 star thing in football. Not every 5 star ends up being a 5 star, and not every 3 star never reaches a 5 star level. I don't know much about Ledlum's game but because he transferred out we don't have to pull the "we didn't want him anyway" and act like he probably wasn't that good because of the league he came from.
I believe he was plenty "good". He found out this might not be the best place for him to play extended minutes and be a "go to" guy. We're sort of loaded with talent. I doubt the cultural difference was much of a factor. After practicing with the group a couple of times, he realized this might not be the place to shine. It's likely that's the case. This MIGHT be Barnes' most talented roster since he's been here.
I donāt know how he, or anyone else, was doing. Everybody agrees to take the offseason reports with a grain of salt, I take them with a boulder of salt
I agree SF brings real info, but like most with real connections to the program, there is often a positive spin in favor of UT. Not criticizing, i appreciate the info nonetheless, I just account for that when I read his posts
How many summer practices did he participate in--two? Nobody can make a decision about how much playing time he might get after a couple of summer practices/scrimmages. There were probably multiple reasons for his decision.
Itās my understanding that the players spend a bunch of time in the gym with each other outside of the allowed organized practices. Iād guess itās not too difficult to determine where you stack up against the competition before Barnes blows the whistle. JMO
Thatās certainly a good possibility, but I still put more stock into what weāve seen him do in real life college basketball games than assumptions made from transfer decisons, well reasoned or not, on his performance in practice. And he looked like a player to me. I get itās the Ivy League and not the SEC, but itās not like the Ivy League is complete garbage either. Iām not saying heād put up 19 here but I expected him to be a really solid contributor, and itās a bummer heās gone. I hope one of Knecht or Mashack can hold up at the 4 for long stretches, bc Iād worry about relying too much on JJJ (health), Tobe (non-shooter), DJ Jefferson, or Estrella (freshman) to do so. I love Jahmaiās game so bummed as I am about Ledlum leaving Iām excited too to see Shack get more on his plateAgree with you 100% that one should largely ignore preseason reporting. Positive spin or not, Stoerner Fumbles has proven to be an accurate source of information which is a very scarce commodity on VN.
But, let's set aside what Stoerner said...Occam's Razor dictates that one of the most likely factors in Ledlum's decision to leave is his perceived ability to compete for, and atain, his desired level of playing time.