Ulysees E. McGill
This season is for you Sweets
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2009
- Messages
- 54,917
- Likes
- 144,840
On potential alone, I would have to say 2018, but that is also taking into account they guys Pruitt got in his first class.
This isnt basketball. Also, we arent worse off than we were when Butch took over. Thats fake news
Coaching is coaching no matter the sport. A good coach will identify and develop talent. And from a perception point we are. 5 years deeper into the abyss of mediocrity, all those players that came here and werent developed, butchs dumb sayings, etc.This isnt basketball. Also, we arent worse off than we were when Butch took over. Thats fake news
And he seems to form opinions without watching a lot of these guys play. I dont know how someone watches Clemons and Harrison and doesnt see that they have tremendous upsideFake news does not mean what you think it means. It does not mean that you have a different opinion. It means something is false. Once again, people are having difficulty distinguishing fact from opinion. I like a lot of your posts, but you have some of the hottest takes (i.e. off the cuff with little analysis) on here.
Fake news does not mean what you think it means. It does not mean that you have a different opinion. It means something is false. Once again, people are having difficulty distinguishing fact from opinion. I like a lot of your posts, but you have some of the hottest takes (i.e. off the cuff with little analysis) on here.
Oh good. We can get this started early and get it out of the way before tomorrow. Here is basically everything that will be said for the next few pages.
"this seems like a reach only a 3 star" ,
"I trust the coaches over sites",
"the same thing was said about butch and dooley",
"what about Sutton",
"they can't all be diamonds in the rough",
"he'll get bumped",
"they never get bumped",
"yer such a negavol",
"I don't do blind faith after the last coach", etc.
2013 also takes into account the guys that Butch got in his first class.
Okay, if the 2018 roster is better, then the situation that Pruitt is walking into is better. He has better players than Butch did.
To say that Butch's 2013 team is better than the 2018 team is not opinion, it is fake news.
Which would you take? 2013 or 2018 roster?
That is not taking into account the absolute and undeniable brokeness of the whole program. That was the worst team and worst UT football program I've ever seen, on the field and in the office...period. It is going to take a lot more work to fix.
Ask me after the season. It is your opinion. One that many people may or may not share. I agree with McGill that last season was the worst one we have ever had. We have questions about talent at multiple positions, with QB and DL, two of the most critical, being among them.
But there are a couple of extra considerations...
1 - Did he have the ultimate say on who to extend offers at Georgia, Bama or FSU? Answer is probably not.
2 - What 3-stars did he REALLY, REALLY want that were passed on or his evaluation was overriden? This is the $64,000 question and very few people are going to know the true answer...him, Richt, Jimbo and Saban. For all we know, he may have predicted a lot of home runs but ended up watching these kids ball out at other schools.
I might very well be wrong, but for him to be jumping on some of these kids months before signing day indicates to me he likes what he sees and doesn't want to let them get away.
I know, I know...this sounds like blind optimism. But I find it extremely hard to believe that he went after some of the super talents he did last year at the 11th hour yet is now taking whomever he can with months to spare. This would make no sense to me.
You said they were curious takes. I took that as meaning you didnt think they were good players
Stats, coaching evals, offers, highlights, etc. there are a number of ways to tell if someone has the ability to be a good player or not. If you trust Pruitt so much why do you care what a player is rated? You think hes taking kids that he thinks wont help us win?How would I know if they are a good player? All I've seen are highlight videos. I think you can read the rest of my posts and see that I have confidence in Pruitt's ability to evaluate and develop talent. Eventually tho, we're going to have to recruit at an elite level if we want to win championships. It may take time, as I have said, so that Pruitt can show progress on the field, but eventually if we want to compete with UGA and Bama we'll have to recruit with them.
Butch dug us further into a hole than many realize. Weve become the premier laughing stock of college football thanks to him. Pruitt is doing just fine. Ask rick Barnes about recruiting and coaching three stars. Good coaches find players they like and help them reach their potential. Pruitt knows what traits elite athletes have. I will trust him all day over any recruiting service.
Stats, coaching evals, offers, highlights, etc. there are a number of ways to tell if someone has the ability to be a good player or not. If you trust Pruitt so much why do you care what a player is rated? You think hes taking kids that he thinks wont help us win?
I get that everyone here wants a top 5 class but thats jumping the gun. We hit rock bottom last year and this staff is going to have to prove to recruits, high school coaches, and parents that they can be trusted unlike the past few coaching staffs. That will 100% take time.