Girl Pressures Boyfriend into Suicide

#201
#201
hog88 said:
In my mind getting someone to kill someone else would require some motivation, money, sex, relationship ext. So I put that in the crime category.

If your mad at someone and I say to you "you should kill that muther f'er, you're a wuss if you don't" even if said 1000 times and you do, I wouldn't say that's a crime on my part.

In this case you might very well call this the perfect crime, I don't know. I could see a civil case.
Click to expand...

So if she told him she would have sex with him if he killed himself you think it's a crime, but it's not if she harasses him?
 
#203
#203
Here's a different scenario hog. Let's take the exact same situation and move it forward 4-5 years. These same two people are now married. The young lady (now his wife) still knows that her husband suffers from depression and has contemplated suicide in the past... and has been thinking about it again.

Nothing else changes in this scenario. She sends the exact same text messages and offers the exact same encouragement for her husband to off himself... which he ultimately does. She is now a widow and collects on a fairly nice death insurance package (if that's possible with suicide). She also sends out the same texts after his death talking about how she wish she could have saved him... even though she's the one who put him up to it.

Do you still think no crime was committed on her part? imo she should absolutely be incarcerated.
 
#205
#205
jjay2518 said:
Ummm...he agrees, they have sex, he kills himself? I thought that was pretty straight forward.
Click to expand...

The way it was phrased was that he kills himself, then she agrees to have sex with him.

I'm betting that is probably how it went down the more I think about it.
 
#206
#206
IBlvNTmWrk said:
Here's a different scenario hog. Let's take the exact same situation and move it forward 4-5 years. These same two people are now married. The young lady (now his wife) still knows that her husband suffers from depression and has contemplated suicide in the past... and has been thinking about it again.

Nothing else changes in this scenario. She sends the exact same text messages and offers the exact same encouragement for her husband to off himself... which he ultimately does. She is now a widow and collects on a fairly nice death insurance package (if that's possible with suicide). She also sends out the same texts after his death talking about how she wish she could have saved him... even though she's the one who put him up to it.

Do you still think no crime was committed on her part? imo she should absolutely be incarcerated.
Click to expand...

No. I also wouldn't have a problem with the insurance company denying her claim, if his policy paid on suicide.
 
#210
#210
She didn't just encourage him. She went as far as to research, plan and tell him step by step how to do it. I know the Bible doesn't hold much weight to people anymore but the way I see it is that God didn't change his mind on "Thou shall not commit murder". No one has the right to take a life, including their own. Suicide is murder. Just personal opinion, but I do believe this was an attention thing for her. If she was just done with hearing the suicide talk she should've been the one to change the subject when it came up. She brought it up and berated him for not wanting to talk about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#212
#212
Good, that girl is crazy and obviously didn't give a crap about that guy.
 
#213
#213
salutethehill said:
I hope yall don't seriously think he offed himself because of her. Sure, she didn't help, and she should be ashamed, but she didn't kill him.
Click to expand...

and Muslim clerics who brainwash suicide bombers aren't responsible?
You ought to think about what you are going to type before you type it.
 
#221
#221
It's sad, but I'm surprised by the verdict. I bet Trump/famous athletes receives 1000's of text's encouraging them to kill themselves from looney tunes. But it would be foolish to blame a text if something did happen.
 
#223
#223
vols-1 said:
It's sad, but I'm surprised by the verdict. I bet Trump/famous athletes receives 1000's of text's encouraging them to kill themselves from looney tunes. But it would be foolish to blame a text if something did happen.
Click to expand...

Its a Federal crime now
 
#224
#224
vols-1 said:
It's sad, but I'm surprised by the verdict. I bet Trump/famous athletes receives 1000's of text's encouraging them to kill themselves from looney tunes. But it would be foolish to blame a text if something did happen.
Click to expand...

Apples to oranges
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#225
#225
vols-1 said:
It's sad, but I'm surprised by the verdict. I bet Trump/famous athletes receives 1000's of text's encouraging them to kill themselves from looney tunes. But it would be foolish to blame a text if something did happen.
Click to expand...

The guy thought he was in a relationship with the girl. Kinda different than a complete stranger tweeting "go kill your self" at you.

The case is tricky because the guy was already displaying suicidal tendencies. She just encouraged him to follow through.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top