He's still a very young coach, most are just now getting their first HC gigs. Maybe he will be great, maybe not. If you look at hiring a Kiffin vs a coordinator or FCS coach I think if you account for risk, Lane is lower risk with higher chance to breakthrgh to a great coach.
No, after the last 13yrs ...8-4 for 4-5yrs is perfectly fine with me. I would be ecstatic about it as long as we were running the program correctly. I.e. recruiting well, redshirting guys, developing, and building something that can last. That was the issue with Butch.. 8-4 doesn't matter when it's clear you are screwing everything else up.