- Joined
- Feb 2, 2005
- Messages
- 93,775
- Likes
- 65,428
To answer that question gets back to the patent system in general (which would certainly include a heated debate). The short answer is that, whether or not there were devices before that could do the same thing, in the eyes of the USPTO, Apple's patent application described a viable innovation.
that's my main issue. They didn't invent they just tweak and then patent.