I'll be the first one to admit high school tape may not amount to a hill of beans, but with Dobbs those tapes and early reports are all we have to go on. He may be awful for all I know. But him being a true freshman does not exclude him from consideration (especially for a kid who is mature beyong his years). Manning, Ainge, Bray did pretty well as true freshman in the SEC and that's just from UT.
While Worley's HS tape was also good, I have a lot more information (better information) to draw on for an opinion about him as a QB. JMHO, I've seen him in big games, mop up duty, spring games, and frankly I thought he was below average in every situation. I feel like we have a much better idea of what we have in Worley and from my vantage point, it is not impressive. I felt the exact same way with Simms.