Multiple players and recruits have stated publicly that their decisions were influenced by the social media of programs. I wouldn't imagine one or two negative posters would have a lot of influence. Volumes of negativism... do. They also influence media members who DO frequent various boards for material.Doubling down on stupid I see lol it’s like having a pet unicorn. I know we all want to believe our thoughts and words are exceptionally profound but the reality is if every potential recruit was turned off by negative fan base opinions then they wouldn’t be able to commit to a single school.
This isn't an issue of personal vanity on the part of those who want to keep a minimal level of respect and tone in the conversation. It could be a matter of ego to believe you can throw a (virtual) tantrum and run someone down while expecting them to just "understand".
Someone close to me right now is going through a divorce. His soon to be ex can't understand why she can't scream at him to avoid criticism then have him treat her like a princess.
I would guess that most of us either directly or indirectly react to emotion motivated negative people. Some confront. Most... avoid.
Criticizing this or any other kid while they're going through a process that we really have no direct knowledge about... is stupid and if done enough by enough people can have a negative effect.