Orangeburst
Attention all Planets of the Solar Federation
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2008
- Messages
- 46,337
- Likes
- 105,442
It wasn't a great bill to begin with. Nevermind that the only reason Democrats got behind it was the for the election year bump........ In fact they'd been on the full court press trying to convince everyone that the people against open borders were racists and there wasn't even an issue with illegal immigration to begin with only a few months before.Its well documented fact. I know you don't like it and it's embarrassing to Trump supporters who say on the one hand this is a critical issue that must be solved, but on the other hand pledge their fealty to the guy that blocked it.
But it definitely happened and has been discussed by several Republican congress people.
First of all, that's talking specifically about illegal immigrants. OP was about all immigration. Also, that's probably the most biased think tank on the matter.
Responsible research by the Petersen Institute, the Brookings Institution, and the congressionally-chartered National Academy of Science finds that immigration is a net economic gain for the nation and a net fiscal positive for the federal budget. This includes undocumented immigration. A University of California - Los Angeles analysis found that a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants would generate $1.5 trillion in gross domestic product growth over 10 years, more than $350 billion in tax revenue (more than enough federal funding required to cover every uninsured person in the United States through Medicaid for a year), and more than 370,000 jobs.
The Subcommittee on Immigration Integrity, Security, and Enforcement did not call witnesses from these research institutions. Instead, the majority sought the input of partisans like Steven Camarota, of the Center for Immigration Studies, an organization described by the Southern Poverty Law Center as “an anti-immigrant hate group,”
BTW, my Dad is a conservative who has Fox News type opinions about immigration, but he was a research economist for the National Academy of Science, and he will tell you they do good work. Everybody knows CIS is a joke.
What/Who is CIS?
It is true..the Repubs or Dems could fix this overnite just by employment enforcement and penalties…but no denying that Dems make it much worse with incentives and ease.
It wasn't a great bill to begin with. Nevermind that the only reason Democrats got behind it was the for the election year bump........ In fact they'd been on the full court press trying to convince everyone that the people against open borders were racists and there wasn't even an issue with illegal immigration to begin with only a few months before.
You left out a lot of very important contextualizing details. If you're going to call it one side for using illegal immigration as a political football you need to call everyone out equally or shred your credibility/intellectual honesty.
so racist, they even prepare testimony to Congress..give me a break. Labeled by the far left SPLC, which can be called a Communist org by the same standard as it had publishings in communist papers..SPLC is a hate group themselves.
I don't watch Fox, I actually prefer CNN for straight news from a domestic source but I don't trust their political analysis because of their slant.You read through the bill and Congressional analysis?
I dont believe that for a tenth of a second. You heard it from some whiny Fox talking head and want it to be true so bad.
Feel like commenting on the kill switch written into the Bill yet? This is the 9th time I’ve asked.You read through the bill and Congressional analysis?
I dont believe that for a tenth of a second. You heard it from some whiny Fox talking head and want it to be true so bad.
Stay in Mexico says hi.Farming/ranching/food producing industry is overwhelmingly red and by far is the biggest user of illegal labor....
If the Rs enforced the laws on the books for labor in those 3 industries, illegal immigration would be significantly cut.....
Immigration, just like gun control for the left, is just a talking/fundraising point for elections. They've had chances to fix and chose not to....
Iirc 13% went to border issues. It was a foreign war funding bill in an immigration wrapper. Dems thought they could shame enough into voting for it. If it's actually useful then pass it on its own merits. Shouldn't be too hard right? Meanwhile they can enforce the many rules on the books as a startYou read through the bill and Congressional analysis?
I dont believe that for a tenth of a second. You heard it from some whiny Fox talking head and want it to be true so bad.
you mean it would have said a lot of words, given a lot of money away, and done nothing to fix the actual problem.Democrats had joined with Republicans to draft up a bill that would have really helped with this. Was all ready to go...
Then Trump called his minions in Congress and told them to block it because he doesn't want progress to be made prior to the election.
^ Conflating legal immigrants with illegal aliens, when the topic at hand is clearly illegal aliens flooding over the border.
you mean it would have said a lot of words, given a lot of money away, and done nothing to fix the actual problem.
The only improvement was that there was a limit on the number of Mexicans or Canadians that could cross the border on any given day. a limit that the president could get rid of whenever he wanted. a limit that decreased over time, while increasing the president's ability to remove it.
if you aren't from Mexico or Canada there is no limit on how many can cross.
in truth the far better option would have been to flip that. no limit on Mexicans and Canadians, but all the others were limited.
how was a law going to speed up a process in the courts?It would have dramatically sped up asylum hearings so that instead of looking for people 5 years down the road when their case finally came up, it would have been just a few months.
You guys keep comparing this to what you think is the Trump plan of ZERO illegal immigrants coming in, which is a fool's errand and can never occur. Trump was thwarted by the courts a number of times when he tried to act as POTUS, and in fact Trump himself while in office called for legislation precisely to expedite these processes.
Until he feared it would have helped Biden to have it pass on his watch.