I think you would have to rank Pearl ahead of Purnell and probably ahead of Hewitt, and definitely ahead of Lowe. I would say he is third in the SEC behind Donovan and Calipari. Many people on here don't think Pearl is just a terrible coach, but we see glaring weaknesses that are going to have to be fixed before Tennessee sees any big time success.
Thanks. Once the smoke clears I find that I actually agree with most of the people who are on here who argue with me more than I thought I did.
In the ACC I would say he is a better coach than those guys, and not as good of a coach at this point as Coach K (though he compares favorably the last 4 years) and of course Roy Williams. But guess what? Neither is almost anyone else!
There is a lot of space between "Bruce Pearl is not terrible" and what people who are realistic have to see, which is for getting publicity Bruce Pearl is a top 5 coach. For recruiting he may be approaching the top 10, he is hampered by Adidas but if T Harris and Hopson pan out and Wayne and Tyler S can stay on rosters he should stay in the top 10 firmly as a recruiter. The guy has been selling himself and his program with no NBA success, now he is on the cusp of some.
Bruce Pearl is probably the third best coach in the SEC, and would be top 5 in the ACC and top 4 or higher in every conference but the Big East. That is a very elite level coach. If he stays for 20 years, you and others are understandably concerned he will never get UT to the Final Four, but some of us believe he will and that he could stick around because he knows he can become UT's Jim Boeheim. I said on another thread if he wins an NC I could see him leaving for the NBA, but I think maybe he will learn the Pitino lesson and know you cannot recruit in the NBA and you actually have to spend more time on X's and O's than he wants to.
Bruce Pearl could be a top 20 CBB coach for the next 2 decades. If he does that this program will be at a height it never reached previously and will be in great shape to maintain that top level status.
I think the SEC is still better than the Big 10, but not by much at all. No one is crazy enough to think that the SEC is better than the Big East. The Big 12 just got a great win when Washington went down, which just sends the Pac 10 further into the abyss. It is kind of surprising how far those programs have fallen as a conference.