Who did we lose that we were supposed to get?
That 6'10 OT is the only one off the top of my head. But you can keep saying "who did we lose that we were supposed to get?" every year. Such a silly criteria. It doesn't mean you had a good recruiting class. It doesn't mean you didn't finish at the bottom of the conference.
What has this guy ever accomplished? I see he was at Flordia as WR coach for one year under Urban Meyer and the receivers were so poor UF fans were happy to get rid of him. I don't see any other impressive jobs on his resume or any major accomplishments. I don't see any testaments to some kind of recruiting prowess. Why is this guy on our staff and why is he our recruiting coordinator?
To be fair I see Dooley and his staff being more to blame for the recruiting class. The current staff did improve on the abomination of a recruiting class that they inherited from Dooley and company. Hopefully most of these guys signed will perform beyond expectations, because if they don't it is going to continue to hurt this football team for 4 years.
I never thought that I would see a UT recruiting class ranked behind Vanderbilt, but that really should be expected after 6+ years of futility on the field and a revolving door of coaches.
Why must all you Vollyannas use a straw man argument? I know the facts aren't on your side, but you could certainly be more creative. No one expected Butch Jones to land a top 10 class. The problem is, he finished 11th in the SEC, behind Vanderbilt. He didn't gain any ground on anyone. If anything, he fell further behind.
Did he inherit a bad situation? Sure. But if you don't take big steps in improving that situation, it's never going to get any better. And I don't see Jones making any strides like the others who have been able to pull themselves out of the difficult situations they inherited. I mean, Hugh Freeze and James Franklin didn't walk into great situations either, but from the outset, you could see them making strides to improve things.
YES....Dooley is the main culprit for our signing day. One poster said nobody expected Jones to come in and sign a top 10 class....well, we had a top 20 class. What were ya'll expecting, 11th? He had 31 days to actually be out there recruiting! If we have a 20th or worse ranked class next year, then yes, we can start the panic.
Vanderbilt was ranked ahead of us by 1 spot!!! They signed 26, we signed 21. If we would have taken anybody else, we would have been "ranked" higher. I would rather have our class than theirs. Instead, we have more spots for next year that we can take kids that we build relationships with.
Here's a hint: if you're even close with Vanderbilt, if you're saying "we almost caught them", if you're saying "we were just a spot behind" (or just 7 spots behind, according to ESPN), then your class is a failure.
Why must all you Vollyannas use a straw man argument? I know the facts aren't on your side, but you could certainly be more creative. No one expected Butch Jones to land a top 10 class. The problem is, he finished 11th in the SEC, behind Vanderbilt. He didn't gain any ground on anyone. If anything, he fell further behind.
Did he inherit a bad situation? Sure. But if you don't take big steps in improving that situation, it's never going to get any better. And I don't see Jones making any strides like the others who have been able to pull themselves out of the difficult situations they inherited. I mean, Hugh Freeze and James Franklin didn't walk into great situations either, but from the outset, you could see them making strides to improve things.
Who did we lose that we were supposed to get?
It's not so much about losing someone we were supposed to get at this point as it is actually getting guys other SEC teams want.
I don't know that we signed a single guy yesterday who so much as had an offer from Alabama.
Until the talent gap closes, this program is going to flounder.
Well, god bless you. I hope you're right (I was on board with the Jones hire myself until yesterday). That said, I've seen this all before. I don't want empty promises and subjective notions of "hard work" and "energy". I want results and I don't see any. I would like to think that the rebuilding has started, but I just can't find any evidence that we're gaining ground on anyone.
What has this guy ever accomplished? I see he was at Flordia as WR coach for one year under Urban Meyer and the receivers were so poor UF fans were happy to get rid of him. I don't see any other impressive jobs on his resume or any major accomplishments. I don't see any testaments to some kind of recruiting prowess. Why is this guy on our staff and why is he our recruiting coordinator?
Do you put that on Jones?
He passed the first test he was in on 4 or 5 to the last hour he had been recruiting these players for 8 weeks the other coaches have been recruiting them for a year or two.Only way to get evidence for or against Jones is to watch the games at this point.
His first test was signing a solid recruiting class and adding difference makers as much as possible.
He failed that test yesterday IMO. It was a solid class by Big East standards but won't help in the SEC. Hopefully, he learned from the experience.
Win a few more games than they lose and get some positive momentum building for this program again this upcoming season. That's the next test.