Squirrel I think had a less than expected year due to timidness from playing injured most of the season. He’s known for acrobatic catches but he made the routine look hard leaving his feet way too often and I think maybe it was part habit expecting off target passes and part trying to protect himself since he was injured. Nimrod had a bad year with drops, maybe that’s what kept him off the field in the past when his speed and development were hyped? Not sure why Webb didn’t make the field over nimrod, seemed to be an athletic pass catcher with a large catch radius, at least in practice. Maybe they prioritized nimrods ability to create separation and he just let them down by not capitalizing.
I think the staff values being dependable and bru, while not much of a threat to create separation, was the most dependable blocker and pass catcher. Deonte Thornton has the best speed. He did average like 25 yards a reception. He had plenty of big plays. He also had a couple key non-plays, specifically an easy third down drop against uga, and a non effort against osu.
When I look at our group versus others, it doesn’t appear to be that much different than elsewhere. For example, a lot of us might trade spots with uga because of their depth of top tier talent, but I don’t know that I would have traded receiver rooms with them this year. The only receiver rooms that were definitively better than ours were in the elite category this year: Osu, Texas, Miami, bama (whose lost some of those guys to portal too), to name a few. I think the offensive line taking time to jell and Nico still being relatively inexperienced as a passer was glaring. It’s just a shame that this group didn’t have one more year to put it all together.
I think biggest thing is we are still in a spot where we need to play above our talent level to beat the best and any inconsistency looks like a clear deficiency. Losing the depth is not a good look but I hope the staff is letting this play out the way it is because they are planning to upgrade mightily as opposed to stalling and not being able to take the next step. It’s hard to see that happening but they have come up with a couple key players in the portal recently so I’m hopeful they can patch the holes and make another playoff run next year, albeit with hopefully a different first round outcome.
I do think in addition to adding some key playmakers, we will need to assess the coaching staff and determine why in big games we are not able to scheme our way into a position to win and instead appear to have less to offer than in other games. That is a concern that needs to be addressed. Great competitors play their best when the opposition is greatest, and we don’t seem to have that extra gear. The players are what they are. That part comes down to coaching.