They went 11-5 the year he was injured with Matt Cassel, iircAnd look at the Pats without Brady (this year and the year he was injured).
And now he's led the BUCS to a super bowl at 80 years old haha. Look - love Peyton - and NOBODY can take from him what he did - but don't see how this is even disputable. If Brady had retired 5-6 years ago, then it would have been a decent debate. But TB has only solidified his place.