I agree with some of the other posters here. I think Dormady is the best QB we have, especially for a less QB run-oriented offense. His play in the second halves of the GT and Florida games were the best QB play we had all season. I believe that his shoulder injury really affected his game and made him scared to get hit. I think he comes back healthy and ready to compete for the starting role.
JG was not impressive to me in any way. He seemed to be terrible in the short and mid range passing game. He had no clue how to get rid of the ball when being pursued, and finally, his ability to run actually hurt Tennessee's offense because he was too quick to scramble on every play. I'm not saying I'm giving up on him, but I think he has more to prove than Dormady.