7/19/1946 - Umpire ejects 14 White Sox
The events that transpired in Boston's 9-2 victory over the Chicago White Sox have been the subject of controversy since it occurred on July 19, 1946. All 14 players and coaches on the Chicago bench were ejected by umpire Red Jones, and legend has it that it was all caused by a ventriloquist in the stands.
In the top of the third inning, Chicago pitcher Joe Haynes came in high and tight with a fastball to Ted Williams. Jones issued a warning to the Sox pitcher, which sparked an argument from the Chicago dugout. One voice continued to chide the umpire, so Jones ejected the quiet Ralph Hodgin. He was not the culprit, and Jones ejected three more White Sox. The other players began to pipe up and complain. Jones, to make absolutely sure he was rid of the heckler, ejected everyone in the White Sox dugout.
The players futilely argued with Jones before making their way back to the clubhouse. Manager Bing Miller offered his glasses to Jones, saying, "You need 'em more than I do."
Play resumed with every possible antagonist ejected. Or so Red thought, for within a few seconds a voice rang out, "Hey meathead, let's see some hustle before the home folks!"
In 2006, the New York Times published an article indicating that the heckler was Sox bench coach Mule Haas. A Ralph Schoenstein article in 1963 was used as evidence; the column stated that, "After the bench had been cleared, Red heard one lone tenor voice that still insisted he was a meathead. He went to the dugout and saw a big windbreaker hanging in the corner. Protruding from it were two feet with spiked shoes. He grabbed the windbreaker from the nail, uncovering Mule Haas, a White Sox coach."
Third baseman Dario Lodigiani added his testimony that it was Haas, although other living players from that game disagreed. It's hard to navigate the truth when the witnesses of history are either senile or dead. But it appears as though a coach and not a ventriloquist led to one of the most single-game ejections in baseball history.