Solely from a "I am legitimately creeped out" standpoint, I personally don't think it gets much better than the Paranormal Activities. I know not everyone agrees, but to me, found footage-style is the way to go in terms of horror movies.
I literally just saw this on Facebook, had to post it here. Very fitting for some of us!
The Strangers for me since there are people crazy enough to do stuff like that.
I don't think I slept well for a few weeks because of that movie. Also, I always thought it was cool Merle Haggard had a song in there since his band was called The Strangers
Loved Merle song appearance in The Strangers. I liked the movie and still recommend ppl see it bc of the shock factor and realness. I think if it's "possible" it kinda creeps me out. Much like that.
My younger self would get scared at all the nightmare on elm st movies.. being young in the 90s with older siblings made for some pretty good horror films at a young age lol
Wasn't The Strangers loosely based on a real event? Obviously if no one lived, then the story has to be made up based on evidence...
edit...I was wrong, said it was based on a series of break in murders (Manson murders and Cabin 28 murders)
Great movie though