Yeah he had some bad moments but alot of the negative memories of scotty was bc so much was expected of him.....Bobby Maze was a good player and one of my faves but not one of the focal points of the team.
Is Martin able to fly around and sprinkle magical pixie dust over the tops of players heads and make them that much better as players. The man has not made the NCAA tournament in his coaching history yet. Scotty has been coached by numerous coaches in his playing history including one of the most successful at UT and noone has gotten him to the level you are referring I really doubt Martin would have made a huge impact on him.
Maybe Martin couldn't have made him that much better, but he wasn't ready anyway. It would have been mutually beneficial for both Scotty and UT if he had returned. He would have been the senior offensive influence that we needed early in the season while McRae and Golden were figuring it out, and he would have played another year under a different coach. Additionally, somehow the light came on in January for Martin's first team, and they played excellent defense while beating Florida twice, UConn, and Vandy.
Point is, it wouldn't have hurt him. JMO.