i think he makes the club. time will tell, but he may have the tools that have him showing up the other guys competing for the 5th spot. that being said, i would rather see chapman than maloney personally. leake needs some time in the minors. i don't foresee lehr or kip wells winning the spot over chapman. at least i hope wells doesn't win the 5th spot. i don't want to see him sniff the big leagues in a reds uni unless he is called up to replace an injured player. i have seen very little of chapman, but i feel confident in him being more major league ready than those four right now. we will see how he does against actual hitters in a game situation, but my pick is chapman at this point.