Not at all trying to be overly dismissive of this. So I’ll take some of it point by point. But overall, I just don’t agree that a politician needs to be some sort of true believer or zealot or something.
Yes I see that there are still some members of both parties that at least try to work some together. Sinnema for one, has surprised me. Manchin has always played the game based on who his constituency is. I'm not sold on Sasse, he was a little late to the party and the cynical part of me thinks that he has seen the polls and is trying to save his ass more than all of a sudden achieving enlightenment.
Politicians are no different from lawyers [insert jokes here]. Whether they believe it or not is immaterial. It’s whether they do their job and represent the interests correctly. I wouldn’t vote for Sasse if he were my senator for exactly the reason you identified. I think towing the line for Trump is a sign of bad judgment. His attempt to exit isn’t compelling at this point.
But, it’s a sign that he sees the writing in the wall and if that writing says “shut the **** up and get it done.” Then that’s what they’ll do. Both sides.
Tim Scott's police reform bill was defeated, I believe, by the Democrats.
Correct, but not the point you asked about. It underscores the fact that those two broke the picket line.
Buttigieg has recently made some pretty radical statements regarding Judge Barrett. Was his reconciliation platform an act or is it that he has a hot button issue regarding how he thinks Judge Barrett will impact gay marriage? The cynical side of me says "Why not both?"
I don’t know what he said about Barrett other than that his marriage may be affected. That seems plausible. I think if he campaigned on reconciliation and got elected, he would have attempted to work with Republicans. I think Biden will as well. Whether they can get any to work with them probably depends on the carnage in this election. If Mitch is still speaker, it won’t happen.
Do you really think though, that they have any chance with any of the hot button issues I noted in a previous post?
Most, no. Abortion, second amendment, no. I think Biden is going to make healthcare his primary issue. Republicans will be offered a seat at the table, just like last time. Hard to say whether any will sit. They should. It’s a popular issue. Not saying they should vote for a bill they don’t believe in, but a good faith negotiation would be a big change at this point. I think there is common ground there and in immigration. Because voters on both sides both generally support .
Do you think Biden is strong enough to tell the radicals on the left to STFU so that he can work on reconciliation? Do you think any of the current leaders of the Democrats in Congress are wanting to work with the Republicans to solve some of these issues other than getting their way?
The cynical side of me believes that a politician will say anything to get elected and make deals with the devil for the same result. Biden has been a politician in Washingtom DC for 47 years and he has played and is playing the game. He gets elected, whatever deals he has made will determine who gets what and where we go from here.
I don't trust politicians.
They are all political animals and sometimes have to consider the make up of the voters who put them there. Too bad it isn't all the time, so I get what you are trying to allude to.
I just don't see the politicians you listed, as well as Biden, if elected, bucking the Democrat establishment, their agenda and their goals. As long as the congressional leadership is made up of Pelosi and Schumer, and all the committee heads are the like of Schiff and Waters, nothing is going to change in Washington.
I just fundamentally disagree that a politician has to believe in something to get a job done. Trump doesn’t believe in jack ****. Bernie Sanders seems like a true believer. Which one do you think has been more effective? Trump has advanced grievance populism more in the last 4 years than Bernie did in the prior 30. I think Buttigieg is much more progressive than his platform, but he saw what the electorate wanted and offered it. He just banked on Biden fizzling out and was wrong.
Biden has already firmly broken with the progressives on multiple issues. He doesn’t strike me as somebody who believes strongly in anything. His career has been acting on voter mandates. And he clearly knows what this mandate is because he’s still campaigning with an eye toward picking off moderate republicans.
If democrats take the senate I think they will generally follow his lead rather than vice versa. If they try to do something crazy, like nuke the filibuster and dissolve the insurance industry, that would be on their heads the next time the electorate has a chance to say something.