This was a theory about the Holly Bobo abduction posted by someone on the Blink on Crime site. The details are chilling...
TN LADY WHO CARES said...
"My theory as to what may have taken place on April 13th, 2011. I do not claim to know this as fact, just that sometimes "my gut" is spot on and wanted to share with others in hopes it helps someone, somewhere, mostly Holly.
1. Holly is leaving for school and is snuck up on from behind and upon turning around is punched in the nose by someone she is fimilar with - an acquantice of her father's who feels put off, jealous or just obessed with Holly, OR her ex-boyfriend 20 something grocery employee, not Drew, which leaves a small amount of blood on the carport. I say the blood found is hers because of a statement made by the TBI lady - it was not a life threatening amount of blood and we believe she could be alive (paraphrased). Which says to me the blood is Holly's.
2. Stunned, Holly is lead by the arm into the woods.
3. Her brother catches a glimpse of movement through his window and sees what he thinks is Holly and her exboyfriend walking toward the woods. He resumes his activites thinking nothing more of it. They're young siblings and respect each others privacy and don't get involved until asked..imo.
4. Several minutes later a neighbor hears a woman scream from the direction of Holly's home so she calls the home to see if everyone is ok. I think this is when he stops to put the duck tape on her mouth and as he is doing so she screams.
5. The brother is concerned by the neighbor's call and goes outside to check on Holly when he sees blood on the driveway and calls his mother. The neighbor calls 911 after hanging up with the brother. The brother then calls the boyfriend(s) and then 911 after learning they are not with Holly.
6. Holly and prep have been on the ATV making their way through the woods toward the ponds South of her home. I believe he transported her by ATV behind the neighbors' properties -how the neighbor heard the scream, and then across the road where there are no houses and continued through to the water.
7. I believe the prep took Holly to the smaller pond behind the longer one deeper into the woods and had his way with her and then using anchors he had there put her in the pond. Yes I think this was premediated.
8. I believe as he was on his way home he started spreading Holly's things away from the crime scene to lead police in the wrong direction. After cleaning up his self, clothes, ATV he joined the search party to stay on top of the investigation and to know when to run.
9. I believe he could still be planting things to throw off the searchers and police.
10. I think the searchers have been called back today because they are going to retrieve her body.
This is all just my opinion and "gut" from gaining clues and info from the reports and comments of others on the boards and facebook. I pray that I am wrong."