Interesting. Modern metrics really don't capture McNair. He would glide along until you really needed a 3rd and 7 pick up. He would elevate to the situation.
He has had the pleasure of stat padding against the NFC East for 6 games per year. Witht he exception of a few years of good eagles teams, it is pretty weak competition. He destroys bad teams and just doesn't get things done at playoff time. Would Titans fans be OK with that? Putting up big numbers and then tripping on his shoelaces in the playoffs? People wanna talk about stats, look at his stats aginst playoff teams and when he is actually in a playoff game. He has a handful of good games, but mostly average to bad.
The infatuation with Top 5 qb is that he is the highest paid qb in the league. He's making more per year than anyone else, his performance does not match that, and it becomes a hinderance to what team you can build. What PFF ranks him is irrelevant to me. If you ask anyone what qb you want leading your team on a final drive, Dak probably won't even get mentioned. He doesn't make other offensive players better, and he's not able to compensate for shortcomings in other positions. When you have to improve the other offensive players around your 60 million dollar qb for him to play well, you know someone in your org f****d up.
