The Problems with Trans-ideology

#6,177
#6,177
Vol8188 said:
Semenya was one of the three women mentioned in the article Nash first shared




Lmfao XY chromosomes = “not a man in any sense”

I imagine I’ll have to explain to Nash again in another month
Click to expand...
As enjoyable as it is to watch you publicly expose yourself as enough of a weirdo to think someone born with a vagina is a biological male, I'm not sure why you want to create arguments out of nothing so badly
 
#6,179
#6,179
NashVol11 said:
This is not a "women's rights" issue, being anti-trans hurts women too. At least you stopped acting like you're the spokesperson for biological women
Click to expand...
Okay, another woman here.. the trans stuff, they take away from women, which they do as evidenced by the sports stuff and girls losing scholarships and all of their hard work..it hurts women… they aren’t women.. and I don’t care what type of surgery they have.. they will never actually be a women.. your DNA, skeletal structure, and chromosomes cannot be altered.. what they do need, however, is self love and some psychological help
 
  • Like
Reactions: CBVols, MemphisVol77 and whodeycin85
#6,181
#6,181
LadyVolette said:
Okay, another woman here.. the trans stuff, when they take away from women, which they do as evidenced by the sports stuff and girls losing scholarships and all of their hard work..it hurts women… they aren’t women.. and I don’t care what type of surgery they have.. they will never actually be a women.. your DNA, skeletal structure, and chromosomes cannot be altered.. what they do need, however, is self love and some psychological help
Click to expand...
How many women have lost scholarships to trans athletes? People are now throwing weird outrage at women who were born women like Imane Khelif today
 
#6,182
#6,182
NashVol11 said:
Sure did, in exactly the way I said they did. First was about genitalia, now it's not when idiots want to be outraged
Click to expand...

Genitalia have never been the defining factor. It’s often used as a stand in because it’s easier than genetic testing.

But the fundamental basis of determining male vs female is the presence of a Y chromosome. If you got one, you’re a man.

You can joke about it all you want, but I imagine even someone as ignorant as yourself understands that fundamental principle
 
  • Like
Reactions: MemphisVol77
#6,183
#6,183
Vol8188 said:
Someone’s just trolling now. Have your fun.
Click to expand...
Yeah someone is. You know good and well that there have been millions of people saying womanhood = born with a vagina and you're just telling me you're personally not one of them. I don't care. There is nothing to argue about there and you're doing it anyway
 
#6,184
#6,184
NashVol11 said:
Yeah someone is. You know good and well that there have been millions of people saying womanhood = born with a vagina and you're just telling me you're personally not one of them. I don't care. There is nothing to argue about there and you're doing it anyway
Click to expand...

That’s why what you’re doing is trolling. Because you’re taking an incomplete definition used by the masses and pretending that to be the determining factor.

XY= male
XX=female

Proclaiming someone who is xy is a woman, is an outright falsehood and a poor troll job by you because it’s easier than admitting the truth…that you were wrong
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpaceCoastVol and LadyVolette
#6,185
#6,185
Vol8188 said:
Genitalia have never been the defining factor. It’s often used as a stand in because it’s easier than genetic testing.

But the fundamental basis of determining male vs female is the presence of a Y chromosome. If you got one, you’re a man.

You can joke about it all you want, but I imagine even someone as ignorant as yourself understands that fundamental principle
Click to expand...
No jokes necessary, there are plenty of people with conditions to where they are XY and female. You may personally disagree with that, and good for you, but there's no point in going back and forth with you trying to make your niche personal opinion into a fact
 
#6,186
#6,186
Vol8188 said:
That’s why what you’re doing is trolling. Because you’re taking an incomplete definition used by the masses and pretending that to be the determining factor.

XY= male
XX=female

Proclaiming someone who is xy is a woman, is an outright falsehood and a poor troll job by you because it’s easier than admitting the truth…that you were wrong
Click to expand...
"Used by the masses?" Lmao you're saying it's the definition everyone uses and they're all wrong? This is exactly why it's a useless point, you're just preaching a minority personal opinion and trying to act like it's more than that
 
#6,187
#6,187
NashVol11 said:
"Used by the masses?" Lmao you're saying it's the definition everyone uses and they're all wrong? This is exactly why it's a useless point, you're just preaching a minority personal opinion and trying to act like it's more than that
Click to expand...

Lmfao it’s a minority personal opinion that xy=male
 
  • Like
Reactions: GroverCleveland
#6,188
#6,188
NashVol11 said:
No jokes necessary, there are plenty of people with conditions to where they are XY and female. You may personally disagree with that, and good for you, but there's no point in going back and forth with you trying to make your niche personal opinion into a fact
Click to expand...

Name any one condition that results in an XY “female” human.

I’ll wait
 
  • Like
Reactions: LadyVolette
#6,190
#6,190
And this is all about Caster Semenya anyway, who was barely mentioned and isn’t trans. Go make your own thread about her
 
#6,192
#6,192
NashVol11 said:
As enjoyable as it is to watch you publicly expose yourself as enough of a weirdo to think someone born with a vagina is a biological male, I'm not sure why you want to create arguments out of nothing so badly
Click to expand...
Getting this book may help you in your journey ... I happily provided a link to order below.

1722569189107.png

www.amazon.ca

Matt Walsh: books, biography, latest update

Follow Matt Walsh and explore their bibliography from Amazon.com's Matt Walsh Author Page.
www.amazon.ca
 
  • Like
Reactions: marcusluvsvols
#6,196
#6,196
SpaceCoastVol said:
WiLIAm Thomas is male
Click to expand...
Lia Thomas was born a biological male, and went by another name (I assume William).

She now identifies as a transgender female. She is not a biological female, and I do not believe she belongs in a pool vs biological females.

But I will respect her choice of name and pronouns. Her going by Lia hurts no one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KptVFL and MemphisVol77
#6,199
#6,199
Something else to add (of which I was not previously aware) is some intersex folks with female anatomy (uterus) and a Y chromosome can conceive, bear, and deliver children. Would these folks be considered men?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 85SugarVol and NashVol11
#6,200
#6,200
gcbvol said:
Something else to add (of which I was not previously aware) is some intersex folks with female anatomy and a Y chromosome can conceive and deliver children. Would these folks be considered men?
Click to expand...
I am a nurse.. and have never seen such a thing.. there are extremely rare anomalies.. but I did some OB mother- baby early on..I did see babies born with their intestines outside of their bodies some though.. and that is probably more likely to happen then what you are describing.. also saw a baby with their organs flipped (what belongs on the right was on the left)… There are also girls born XXX which is a chromosomal mutation
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vol since 77 and GroverCleveland
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top