I agree with your post IE. I am not a big fan of O'Neill, but ya gotta give the guy what little credit he does deserve. He took a very talented Marquette team to the Sweet 16. Once.
Its ironic how some will bash Pearl for not making it past the Sweet 16, but they glorify O'Neill for making it TO the Sweet 16. (Once!) O'Neill can bring in some talent, but he never sticks around to coach them. The basis for bashing and glorifying are the same thing on this board. Hypocrisy at its finest.
It all boils down to being biased towards one coach or the other.
For the record - Given his track record and given the situation at USC currently, O'Neill has nearly zero shot at any meaningful success.