Rasputin_Vol
"Slava Ukraina"
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2007
- Messages
- 72,056
- Likes
- 39,844
For those that do not know, the map showing the 9th Circuit (or what was at one time called the 9th Circus). Very significant ruling.Huge win this week in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
Judge Collins, in his concurring opinion states “a competent person has a constitutionally protected liberty interest in refusing unwanted medical treatment.”
The 9th Circuit today overturned a lower court decision that applied Jacobson. It said this:
Addressing the merits, the panel held that the district court misapplied the Supreme Court’s decision in Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905), in concluding that the Policy survived rational basis review. Jacobson held that mandatory vaccinations were rationally related to preventing the spread of smallpox. Here, however, plaintiffs allege that the vaccine does not effectively prevent spread but only mitigates symptoms for the recipient and therefore is akin to a medical treatment, not a “traditional” vaccine. Taking plaintiffs’ allegations as true at this stage of litigation, plaintiffs plausibly alleged that the COVID-19 vaccine does not effectively “prevent the spread” of COVID-19. Thus, Jacobson does not apply.
9th Circuit Rules Against LAUSD Vaccine Mandate
9th Circuit Court of Appeal rules against LAUSD, reopening lawsuit challenging COVID-era vaccine mandates, religious libertypurposedrivenlawyers.com
Remember when people were suspended from Twitter for claiming that the mRNA jabs were not vaccines but were more like therapeutics. Yeah that really happened.
Some Are Claiming Covid-19 Vaccines Are Not Vaccines
Writer Alex Berenson recently tweeted out the following about the Covid-19 vaccines: “don’t think of it as a vaccine.”www.forbes.com
He didn't have to fire Fauci. He just needed to not let him broadcast nightly on national TV from behind the presidential seal. Trump basically introduced him every night which essentially made Fauci's policies the WH policy. It was an absolute failure in leadershipI agree with this assessment. Firing Fauci would have done nothing. All that would have done is made him available for CNN/MSNBC to just give him unlimited airtime and made him a martyr.
Nice look back.Huge win this week in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
Judge Collins, in his concurring opinion states “a competent person has a constitutionally protected liberty interest in refusing unwanted medical treatment.”
The 9th Circuit today overturned a lower court decision that applied Jacobson. It said this:
Addressing the merits, the panel held that the district court misapplied the Supreme Court’s decision in Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905), in concluding that the Policy survived rational basis review. Jacobson held that mandatory vaccinations were rationally related to preventing the spread of smallpox. Here, however, plaintiffs allege that the vaccine does not effectively prevent spread but only mitigates symptoms for the recipient and therefore is akin to a medical treatment, not a “traditional” vaccine. Taking plaintiffs’ allegations as true at this stage of litigation, plaintiffs plausibly alleged that the COVID-19 vaccine does not effectively “prevent the spread” of COVID-19. Thus, Jacobson does not apply.
9th Circuit Rules Against LAUSD Vaccine Mandate
9th Circuit Court of Appeal rules against LAUSD, reopening lawsuit challenging COVID-era vaccine mandates, religious libertypurposedrivenlawyers.com
Remember when people were suspended from Twitter for claiming that the mRNA jabs were not vaccines but were more like therapeutics. Yeah that really happened.
Some Are Claiming Covid-19 Vaccines Are Not Vaccines
Writer Alex Berenson recently tweeted out the following about the Covid-19 vaccines: “don’t think of it as a vaccine.”www.forbes.com
The CDC defines a vaccine as, “a product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease.”
Unfortunately any POTUS likely would’ve done the same. Trump definitely had missteps but it was a new situation that was a no-win situation.He didn't have to fire Fauci. He just needed to not let him broadcast nightly on national TV from behind the presidential seal. Trump basically introduced him every night which essentially made Fauci's policies the WH policy. It was an absolute failure in leadership
It still wouldn't have mattered. By April 2020/within the first two weeks of "flattening the curve", he would have been on CNN or MSNBC or wherever with the same bully pulpit.He didn't have to fire Fauci. He just needed to not let him broadcast nightly on national TV from behind the presidential seal. Trump basically introduced him every night which essentially made Fauci's policies the WH policy. It was an absolute failure in leadership
He didn't have to fire Fauci. He just needed to not let him broadcast nightly on national TV from behind the presidential seal. Trump basically introduced him every night which essentially made Fauci's policies the WH policy. It was an absolute failure in leadership