Who do you consider the national champion this year?

Who do you consider to be the national champion?

  • Total voters
    0
#76
#76
milohimself said:
Why because there was more media attention? Because it was at a different time of year? Do you realize how stupid that sounds?

At the end of the day they played twice and split. One win does not count more than the other. This isn't soccer
Click to expand...

Because it is the CHAMPIONSHIP GAME that both teams agreed to play.

The stupidest thing here is you arguing it doesn't mean anything.

Bama destroyed them. Want a championship? Don't get destroyed. Not a hard concept.
 
#78
#78
milohimself said:
It's not a playoff game, it's an exhibition
Click to expand...

its the way they all agreed to crown the NC of D1 cfb. I dont like the fact that basketball plays a 1 and done format instead of a best of series but that doesnt mean I dont recognize the winner of MM as NC. Dont whine because its not what you like
 
#79
#79
allvol123 said:
Because it is the CHAMPIONSHIP GAME that both teams agreed to play.

The stupidest thing here is you arguing it doesn't mean anything.

Bama destroyed them. Want a championship? Don't get destroyed. Not a hard concept.
Click to expand...

Why? They already beat them once.

Bama is .500 against lsu. Lsu is .500 against bama. The regular season is part of the championship. Not a hard concept.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#80
#80
milohimself said:
Why? They already beat them once.

Bama is .500 against lsu. Lsu is .500 against bama. The regular season is part of the championship. Not a hard concept.
Click to expand...

Part of it, not the end all be all of it. Bama is the legitimate NC. I'm sure LSU fans can take comfort in being named Milohimself National Champions. Hooray!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#81
#81
milohimself said:
Why? They already beat them once.

Bama is .500 against lsu. Lsu is .500 against bama. The regular season is part of the championship. Not a hard concept.
Click to expand...

happens all the time in basketball yet the winner of their post season is crowned NC. No different in fb.

Not a hard concept
 
#83
#83
allvol123 said:
Part of it, not the end all be all of it. Bama is the legitimate NC. I'm sure LSU fans can take comfort in being named Milohimself National Champions. Hooray!
Click to expand...
Apparently there's only a few people on here that actually understand what I'm advocating (summed up nicely in GahLee's thread), the rest are trolling or just dense.
 
#87
#87
The Giants lost to the Patriots in the regular season, before beating them in the Super Bowl. Should they split the Super Bowl.
 
#88
#88
Question for those of you of the opinion that Bama winning in a shutout somehow counts more: Why does that count in any specific measurable way more than LSU getting their W on Bama's home field?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#90
#90
Milo has solid points, anyone saying otherwise is foolish.

Unfortunately, under the flawed system we have, it's Bama. It's basically a one game playoff, with teams that won popularity contests. A team that is 1-10 could have gone in and beat either team and they would be named national champion by virtue of the rules.

Officially, there is no arguing Bama is the champion.
 
#92
#92
rjd970 said:
Milo has solid points, anyone saying otherwise is foolish.

Unfortunately, under the flawed system we have, it's Bama. It's basically a one game playoff, with teams that won popularity contests. A team that is 1-10 could have gone in and beat either team and they would be named national champion by virtue of the rules.

Officially, there is no arguing Bama is the champion.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Bama was named BCS and AP national champs, which nobody can really dispute because they just were.

What I'm saying is the whole thing is a crock of shat because that one game just rendered the entire 2011 college football season totally useless.
 
#93
#93
milohimself said:
Agreed. Bama was named BCS and AP national champs, which nobody can really dispute because they just were.

What I'm saying is the whole thing is a crock of shat because that one game just rendered the entire 2011 college football season totally useless.
Click to expand...

No argument from me, and one would hope from most in this thread.
 
#94
#94
How many people would feel the same if we had a 4 team playoff consisting of Stanford(didn't win their conf.) vs Bama & LSU vs Okie Lite. LSU & Bama roll, meet up in title game and the same result as last night plays out?
 
#95
#95
PowerT83 said:
How many people would feel the same if we had a 4 team playoff consisting of Stanford(didn't win their conf.) vs Bama & LSU vs Okie Lite. LSU & Bama roll, meet up in title game and the same result as last night plays out?
Click to expand...

It would be more legit than what we got.
 
#96
#96
PowerT83 said:
How many people would feel the same if we had a 4 team playoff consisting of Stanford(didn't win their conf.) vs Bama & LSU vs Okie Lite. LSU & Bama roll, meet up in title game and the same result as last night plays out?
Click to expand...

Even a four team playoff changes the dynamic entirely.
 
#97
#97
Just to clear up on the NFL analogy and why it doesn't work, the biggest difference is that at no point in the NFL season do polls come into the equation. Playoff seeding is based solely on on-the-field results.
 
#98
#98
milohimself said:
Question for those of you of the opinion that Bama winning in a shutout somehow counts more: Why does that count in any specific measurable way more than LSU getting their W on Bama's home field?
Click to expand...

because bama won the NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP GAME
 
#100
#100
milohimself said:
Agreed. Bama was named BCS and AP national champs, which nobody can really dispute because they just were.

What I'm saying is the whole thing is a crock of shat because that one game just rendered the entire 2011 college football season totally useless.[/QUOTE


: :thumbsup:Agree 100% :thumbsup:



GBO
Click to expand...
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top