I agree with most of what you're saying. Some fans spin things in UT's favor no matter what. In fairness though, do you think any unestablished coach could do any better recruiting than Dooley has given the amount of negativity the program has endured over the past few years? I still think we will have a few elite players jump on board if we can show the program is headed in the right direction. Kids are hesitant to jump on a train that has wrecked the past few seasons on and off the field.I wouldn't say they are recruiting "poorly" either. But they certainly aren't recruiting great by any means. I think they are doing about average at this point in time. Unless they make a major move with guys they are sitting 4th and 5th with right now (ie guys like Debell) then they are going to have a similar class to the one's in 08 and 06 in my opinion.
And yes the character comments are retarded. It's just a convenient excuse for landing guys who aren't highly recruited. Tennessee wouldn't have won **** in the 90's if they had ignored kids who didn't necessarily fit into some of the fans definition of "high character" kids.