Q: Just a quick question. FSU has a DT committed in Christmas and he has shutdown his recruitment completely (including camps and stuff) to focus on being a Nole and getting ready for college.
Because of that he dropped in the rankings. I wouldn't have cared if people had passed him and moved up over him but he dropped from a 93 to a 92.
This is after we got a update from our site staff that he had dropped most of his bad weight and looked the best he has ever had during Spring Practice.
Any reason for him dropping when the only new info out about him in the past 4+ months has been positive?
A: (JC Shurburtt) We still have a lot of questions about his ability, if he's OL/DL long term and his ultimate upside. There are a lot of other prospects- linemen and otherwise- we like better.
I think he's one we may end up being wrong on- he and Khari Clark both- if they get it together and perform well this season.
Point is- these rankings are representative of their projections as of right now. That can always change and will be something we continue to monitor.
Q: Thanks I guess my question was if there isn't new material to evaluate on how does a recruit drop in ranking(not the #spot but the %value)?
The questions grow because of a lack of new material to evaulate or another person looked at his film and added to the evaluations?
A: (JC Shurburtt) It's mostly because rankings are comparisons and so many more rise. It's much more mechanized because we order them individually rather than grouping them. I mean prospects are grouped (5 star, 4 star, etc.) but when you are ranking 1-247 you can get to a point where you have to just drop guys out and re-asses.
The reason we dropped Christmas? One "he looks good and like he's lost weight" wasn't enough to counteract the other negatives that forced him down by comparison. It didn't answer the questions. Maybe we kept his projection higher than we should have in hopes that we would get some answers.
And answers don't have to come at camps and combines. We have guys ranked who never camp anywhere.