I'm not knowledgeable enough to opine on any of the remaining non-Ray options, but there's no reason to settle on somebody just for the sake of using up every available scholarship. Why not give the scholarship to a walk-on senior so we have it next year, when we'll hopefully have more momentum on the recruiting trail thanks to a better W-L record and more opportunities for immediate playing time in 2018?
Here are all the guys we may need to replace in 2018:
*QB: One of our backup QBs may transfer
*RB: John Kelly (JR) may declare early for the NFL
*WR: Smith, George, and possibly Jennings (JR)
*TE: Wolf, Johnson
*OL: Kendrick, Thomas, Sanders, Robertson
*DL: Vickers, Mixon, Johnson, and possibly McKenzie, Kongbo and Tuttle
*LB: McDowell, Jumper, El. Berry
*CB: Martin, Moseley, Henderson,
*S: Kelly, Ev. Berry
*K: Medley
*P: Daniel
That's at least 21 scholarship seniors and maybe 1-6 other underclassmen we might be losing. Butch could use that opportunity to find a higher-quality guy next year.