'17 LA RB Trey Coleman (UT signee)

[Smokey123]

Hurd was a 5 star recruit. He missed all of his senior year with an injury so he may have got bumped late in the process.

Hurd was a 4*

 

[VolFreakJosh]

Hurd was a 5 star recruit. He missed all of his senior year with an injury so he may have got bumped late in the process.

Jalen Hurd - Basketball Recruiting - Player Profiles - ESPN

Jalen Hurd, Tennessee, Running Back

 

[Catbone]

Composite 4*

 

[Ulysees E. McGill]

Well Hurd is definitely a freakin 5* now. That's all that matters.

 

[Dobbs 4 Heisman]

Dobbs either...composite 3 star. :question:

Dobbs was a composite 4 star.

But carry on...

 

[Dobbs 4 Heisman]

Hurd was a composite 4*. The last rankings are the one that matters

Actually none of them matter once they hit the field.

Hurd is a 5 star talent whether the idiots at 247 rated him as such or not.

 

[PassedOutAwake]

Composite 3 stars

J. Smith
Foreman
Kendrick
Wiesman
Sutton
Vereen
Wolf
Gaulden
J. Robertson
Mixon
C. Thomas
Moseley
Hall
A. Smith



Meanwhile a ton of our 4 stars haven't done anything yet. Only 9 of our 4 stars (2013/2014 classes) have done anything so far. And that includes guys like Weatherd. Then you have guys who haven't done much like..

Carr - Gone
Mosley
Bryant
Blair - Gone
Helm - Gone
McDowell
Scott - Gone
Hendrix - Gone
Bates
Payne - Gone

 

[Smokey123]

Actually none of them matter once they hit the field.

Hurd is a 5 star talent whether the idiots at 247 rated him as such or not.

Well considering we are talking about recruiting rankings. Yea, it does matter lol we weren't talking about how he has preformed

 

[butchna]

Well considering we are talking about recruiting rankings. Yea, it does matter lol we weren't talking about how he has preformed

^This...he do go back & forth with that star thing doon't he? :w00t:

 

[BaldBiker]

We have had 2 top five classes and the 15th rated class over the last 3 years. You don't get classes rated that highly by taking a lot of 3 star players. Jalen Hurd is our best player and he was a 5 star recruit. Don't get why some people make it seem like we have a team made up of 3 star players.

Tells me you don't know a hell of a lot about the make up of our starting line up.

 

[drvenner]

How come we never have the #allstarsmatter debate in threads where our commits are 4 or 5 star composites?

 

[chargervol]

How come we never have the #allstarsmatter debate in threads where our commits are 4 or 5 star composites?

My guess would be that stargazers aren't b**ching in those threads?
Do I win?

 

[m1al]

A drive by post. Meanwhile, two pages later...


Some need to learn not to be baited so easily.

 

[SCvol333]

Composite 3 stars

J. Smith
Foreman
Kendrick
Wiesman
Sutton
Vereen
Wolf
Gaulden
J. Robertson
Mixon
C. Thomas
Moseley
Hall
A. Smith



Meanwhile a ton of our 4 stars haven't done anything yet. Only 9 of our 4 stars (2013/2014 classes) have done anything so far. And that includes guys like Weatherd. Then you have guys who haven't done much like..

Carr - Gone
Mosley
Bryant
Blair - Gone
Helm - Gone
McDowell
Scott - Gone
Hendrix - Gone
Bates
Payne - Gone

I getcha but our explosive plays on O came from kamara, Hurd, and Dobbs. All highly rated.

On D Jrm, Barnett, and Sutton were like our top players. 2 of those 3 also 4 stars

 

[butchna]

Tells me you don't know a hell of a lot about the make up of our starting line up.

Would actually have to follow the team.

 

[PrattvilleVol]

I don't agree with the guy you are taking umbrage with, at all. But there is a reason there are more 3 Stars in the NFL.

Because there are mathematically more 3 stars to choose from.

 

[Glitch]

Because there are mathematically more 3 stars to choose from.

 

[chavisut]

We've signed a lot of high 3 stars. 5.7

 

[chavisut]

Hurd was a 5 star by Rivals and 247.

Composite meh.

 

[Smokey123]

^This...he do go back & forth with that star thing doon't he? :w00t:

He sure does lol.... "Cam Akers is elite because he's a 5*" "Recruiting rankings don't matters, it matters what he does on the field"

 

[SouthKnoxVOL]

3 stars = mediocrity. It has been proven time and again. Just noticed LSU now has 3 top 100 players after Ausbon's commitment. There is a reason why you sign 4-5 star players. They are FAR more likely to pan out than a 3 star. See Alabama's on field results for a good example of this. When was our last SEC championship …1998.

Man...I tell you what those last few 4* and 5* qb's that LSU has had have really been amazing....lol....kid stfu.

 

[volsfan24017]

Will one of the mods please erase the period after Coleman's name in the thread title? My OCD is killing me.

 

[Go Fight Win]

Will one of the mods please erase the period after Coleman's name in the thread title? My OCD is killing me.

Haha I feel you

 

[Catbone]

They did it!

MODS=GODS

 

[volsfan24017]

YES! Thank you!