I generally have little to no problem with recruiting forum guys as long as they aren't like Sab, seek no direct interaction with recruits, and TRY to have some perspective.
I was drawn to this site because of the recruiting forum and certain posters who brought info they paid for and offered it for free. While their motives might be ego-driven, I did and do appreciate that information.
Recruiting is the life blood of any program and should be taken seriously. But as with all things, a healthy balance is required.