Berry or Matthieu?

[Bassmanbruno]

I said he was 2nd team in an earlier post... still its better than pro bowl alternate.

Rookie vs. 3rd year. Stop homing.

 

[VolBuck24]

Rookie vs. 3rd year. Stop homing.

Malcolm is just a year ahead of berry.

 

[UGA insider]

Berry was a great player while at UT, nobody can deny that.

Still, I would take Matthieu. The guy is a playmaker and should be considered for the Heisman IMO.

 

[Tenn Ted]

Mattheiu has the "IT" Factor. He is more of an impact player on LSU's team than Berry was on Tennessee's team. When the Honey Badger gets it going, so does LSU and then they can't be beat. He was the one that got them going against Georgia. He will play in the pros, but I think he will be a specialist. He is deadly at running back kick-offs and punt returns. His size precludes him being an every down CB.

 

[tvolsfan]

Jenkins has been on better teams. However, he's simply not as good as Berry is. He wasn't in 2008, either.

 

[tvolsfan]

The year he won it is when he deserved it.

Berry was basically playing linebacker the year he won. He basically had the 2009 award won after the 2008 season.

 

[SmokeyHound]

Ive already discussed this but my "friend" EDIT- CLASSMATE and I are having a "debate" as to who is better. its obviously berry but I gotta have proof. Did berry get invited to the heisman awards? and what else could I say besides stats? thanks

 

[Volwark]

There's an ongoing discussion on it here:

http://www.volnation.com/forum/around-ncaa/141000-berry-matthieu.html

 

[SmokeyHound]

thanks

 

[VOLtownUSA]

I feel that if you need help from others to back your argument, you probably should not be arguing about it at all. . .

 

[kevol80]

You could always quit being friends with dumbasses.

 

[SmokeyHound]

not my friend.

 

[thebjd]

Matthieu still has eligibility left so I would take him.

 

[EB14GoVols]

Berry was a top 5 draft pick honey bunny (badger) will not get near that.

 

[kevol80]

not my friend.

 

[tennesseefan31]

There were so many things Berry did that don't show up in a stat book, or even get noticed. UT is maybe half as good a team without him.

 

[TlM]

This is laughable. Do you think Berry would get manhandled one-on-one with Da'Rick?

 

[Govol111]

With orange glassed :Berry

Without :52 Mathieu

 

[Govol111]

With orange glassed :Berry

Without :Mathieu

 

[JAEvans24]

If...

Berry lined up at a 40 yard line

Mathieu lined up at a 40 yard line

and they both took off full speed to collide at the 50

it would look like this...

(i hope freak isnt a PETA member)

 

[PowerT83]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-hqGroNreE[/youtube]

I haven't seen Honey Badger hit anybody like Berry did

 

[WesternKyVol]

Honey badger is better. Just ask him.

 

[Vol2424]

If...

Berry lined up a 40 yard line

Mathieu lined up a 40 yard line

they both took off full speed to collide at the 50

it would look like this...

(i hope freak isnt a PETA member)

That one looks like it's asleep. It would more like this.

 

[orangeluvr]

Yet another useless thread.:whatever:

 

[JAEvans24]

lol, this thread is turning to roadkill; i take full blame

(but yeah, my dead honey badger looks asleep)