A few points:
1. People tend to trivialize what Pearl did. He lied to the governing body of college athletics. He tried to get a recruit and his parents to back up his lie. He committed a major violation in an attempt to dodge a secondary violation. It wasn't about hamburgers and hot dogs, it was about failure to be truthful. If he'd admitted he had them over, chances are very good he'd still be the coach.
2. It does not matter what other schools allegedly did. It's all about what the NCAA can prove. In this case, they didn't even need to do that as Pearl confessed after the fact.
3. No matter what, he wouldn't be coaching at UT this year. He was slapped with a show-cause. If anything, retaining him would have brought about even harsher penalties. Also, Hopson and Harris would still be gone. You think they would have returned to a team under severe NCAA sanctions? No chance. You could also have scratched off any major recruits wanting to come here. When he told that lie, he killed all the progress he had brought to UT. He may have taken us to new heights, but keeping him would have brought us to new lows.
4. How much progression did Hopson show under Pearl? Zero. Pearl could bring in talent, but he could not coach up their skills. He had no idea on how to coach a player's weaknesses and help them get better. He was a great showman and a spectacular salesman, but he was only an average coach. What really killed him IMO was recruiting outside his system. He became too enamored with star rankings and got away from the style of ball he could coach. If he had kept recruiting to his system, we might have been even more successful.
5. Pearl brought something to UT that we needed at the time. Excitement. I don't want to undervalue his accomplishments, but I'm also not willing to turn a blind eye to what he brought upon himself and the university. I appreciate his time here, but I do not miss him. If CCM proves he can coach the kids up, which he has done so far this year, then we have taken a step up. People are crying about the NCAA tournament when, at the beginning of the year, no one would have given us a shot in hell of making it. This team has overachieved. You're fooling yourself if you don't see that. CCM has coached these young men up and deserves to be praised for it.