He made a terrible argument and an erroneous statement. When I called it out he became upset. It has been 15 years since all Florida schools ranked top ten at the same time. The landscape was different when they were.
Ultimately, a strong FSU hurts Florida significantly. If Miami gets their crap together it will become even more difficult.
It's laughable to suggest the state of Florida can't support multiple national title contenders at the same time...or that an "up" FSU makes it significantly difficult for UF to be successful also.
It happened when UF, FSU and Miami all had the right coach. See the 90s and early 00s. The landscape hasn't changed, our demographics aren't changing.
Just because it hasn't happened in a while doesn't mean it won't happen again...take you guys being really good in football for instance.
It's all about who's in charge.
Recently, when UF had the right coach (Meyer), FSU did not (retiring Bowden). And when FSU's had the right coach, UF did not (Muschamp).
I can see two but not all three.
Thanks for the validation.
Over the past 30+ years you can point to the FSU-Miami game or UF-FSU game playing a direct role in the national title picture on at least eight occasions.
The Texas schools can't say that. The California schools can't say that.
Yet based on the misguided opinions of some here we are to believe that UF's football program is toast?
It's absolutely insane to suggest that UF is at some sort of major disadvantage, or in some sort of unrecovable competitive position because FSU is back to being a perennial national title contender.
It sure as hell didn't hurt FSU when Meyer nearly had us playing for three national titles over a four year span. If FSU can bounce back, so can we.
Thanks for the validation.
Over the past 30+ years you can point to the FSU-Miami game or UF-FSU game playing a direct role in the national title picture on at least eight occasions.
The Texas schools can't say that. The California schools can't say that.
Yet based on the misguided opinions of some here we are to believe that UF's football program is toast?
It's absolutely insane to suggest that UF is at some sort of major disadvantage, or in some sort of unrecovable competitive position because FSU is back to being a perennial national title contender.
It sure as hell didn't hurt FSU when Meyer nearly had us playing for three national titles over a four year span. If FSU can bounce back, so can we.
It's easily the worst of the three when you factor in minimal support from the university's administration, apathetic alumni base and no facilities to speak of.
At the end of the day, it takes the right coach. We are quite optimistic that Butch is the right one. If McElwain is the right guy then FL will be back. If either of us is wrong then we may be an 8-9 win team consistently until that's not good enough (Zook, Fulmer) & they are pushed out in search of one that can compete for national titles. I think there are only about 10-20 of those guys in the country.
Looking at this Gators offense (which looks worse and worse all the time) How can the Gators realistically score enough points against Tennessee? I mean that O-Line looks like a worse dumpster fire than Tennessee's was last year, plus only one game breaker on offense (Robinson) and poor QB play? I mean come on!
It's called and opinion. And yes, it surely did hurt FSU when Florida was good. FSU was a shadow of itself then and so was Miami.
BTW, who's saying Florida is dead? That's stupid. The path back might be more difficult but I don't think anyone actually believes you'll be down for good.
Of course, if you keep giving them the reaction they want the instigation is bound to continue.
Thanks for the validation.
Over the past 30+ years you can point to the FSU-Miami game or UF-FSU game playing a direct role in the national title picture on at least eight occasions.
The Texas schools can't say that. The California schools can't say that.
Yet based on the misguided opinions of some here we are to believe that UF's football program is toast?
It's absolutely insane to suggest that UF is at some sort of major disadvantage, or in some sort of unrecovable competitive position because FSU is back to being a perennial national title contender.
It sure as hell didn't hurt FSU when Meyer nearly had us playing for three national titles over a four year span. If FSU can bounce back, so can we.