i think everyone has clear lines on where they stand in this debate....but here's a few things to consider:
TN is virtually the state most devoid of in state football talent in the SEC, with the possible excepitons of maybe KY and ARK. All other states, of schools we compete direclty wiht have rich in state talent, GA, FL, SC, AL, LA, MS
UT recruits nationally in a conference that other schools do not have to. Not to say that other schools don't get national recruiting attention, but look at the rosters and compare the % of instate talet to that of out of state, and i'd bet you'd find UT at the bottom of the list. Given that, i think you still have to consider CPF's entire body of work when evaluating him. Not that there hasn't been downward trend of late, not arguing that at all. No one thinks we are where we should be including me, but i can't ignore what he has accomplished all together...
Since 1990, SEC championships are as follows:
TN:3(1 under Majors, 2 under Fulmer)
UF:6(all under Spurrier)
AL:2(1 under Stallings, 1 under Debose i think)
AU:1(under Tubberville)
GA:2(both under Richt)
LSU:2(both under Saban)
National Titles
LSU:1 (co champions with USC)
TN:1
UF:1
Bama:1
SEC Title game appearances:
UF:7 (none since 2000)
UT: 4 (1997, 1998, 2001, 2004
Bama:5 (none since 1999)
Aub: 3(1997, 2000, 2004)
UGA: 3 (none BEFORE 2002, 10 year absence)
LSU: 3 (none BEFORE 2001, 9 year absence)
ARK:1 (1995)
MSU:1(1998)
Final Polls (AP-Coaches) 1990-2005
8-7
14-15
12-12
12-11
22-18
3-2
9-9
7-8
1-1
8-9
NR-25
4-4
NR-NR
15-16
13-15
NR-NR
Now, i'd be a lot more inclined to be all over him if we weren't competitive in our league over his career, but we have been, and no one can deny that. I think we all agree that things right now are not good and improvement must be seen, but to say he should just be ousted right now, just doesn't fit when you look at the whole career. And before anyone jumps all over me, i already concede that we have not been up to par in the last 5 years or so, and 7 years w/out a championship is too long, but it's not like we haven't been there at all. and no i'm not happy with our performance lately. frankly it has stunk. and no i don't necessarily think CPF is the greatest x's and o's coach in the SEC. And let's also not forget that 5 year period from 95 thru 99 was the most successfull era in UT football history....it wasn't like that was the standard. what i see is a cycle. I also see where we have bounced back from bad years.
but when you look at this, you have to think in terms of long term sustained success, and until lately, we've had that. hopefully in a couple of years, we'll all be looking back on this as really just one bad year, and it's soon forgotten.
it just isn't ALL bad...that's all.