Vol8188
revolUTion in the air!
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2011
- Messages
- 47,213
- Likes
- 45,256
I agree with the part that this is an unacceptable situation. Yes, we have had a ton of injuries, yes there have been a lot of disappointments, but the team to me seems in complete disarray. They've given up.
And that is squarely on Muschamp. I'd fire him if I were Foley.
He is doing what any coach with half a brain should've been doing. Why did Vandy not make many bowl games for years? Because there were only 11 games. You couldn't schedule 4 non-conference cupcakes. Franklin schedules 4 cupcakes and finds ways to get 2 other wins and he's bowl eligible. Couple that with UT stinking since he has been there, UGA and Fla being crippled with injuries this year and he has been able to pick off some low hanging fruit and get to 8 wins the last two years.
I'll give him credit that he has at least won those games when the other Vandy coaches couldn't. However, he has beaten 3 teams with winning records in 3 years. 3. He beat no one with a winning record in his first year, he beat a 7-6 Ole Miss team in his second year, he beat a 7-6 NC State team also in his second year and the other was a UGA team that stands at 7-4 currently. Any team that has been good has usually beaten the brakes off his team. See Mizzou and A & M this year.
Franklin is winning at Vandy. Kiffin could not even win at SC. I hate it too but he is getting it done. Franklin will not be at Vandy long. A team like Florida or SC will pay $$$ for Franklin
I don't mean exactly, but I mean as far as hype as getting it done at the highest level.
I give Franklin credit, but I also continue to point out he's greatly benefitted from a weak schedule combined with some very fortunate times to play the big schools. I think he's a pretty decent gamble for a big program to take a risk on.
I personally thing he has proven enough to move up one more tier. Not to an elite program yet, but I think he gets to anyway because of the coach scramble this off season if it happens the way it looks like it might.
I am not a Franklin fan but he has done an outstanding job at Vandy. Has Vandy every beat TN, GA and FL in the same year before 2013?
Actually, Kiffin was winning at USC. He just wasn't winning enough for a storied program like USC. Plus, his AD didn't hire him.
He went 8-5, 10-2, 7-6 and he was 3-2 when he was fired this year. An overall 28-15 record. He also had beaten 10 teams with winning records. Hell, UT would kill for that right now. And he did it with a ton of scholarship sanctions.
If you can't see that Franklin is a good coach, recruiter, and motivator then you are just blinded by your hate of their rise and our decline. That's the honest truth. He wins games, his players love him, and Jesus he gets top 25 recruiting classes at Vandy.
If we had their schedule the last couple of years and their fortune of playing teams with crippling injuries we'd be pretty damn close. Anyone with half a brain could've coached that team last year to 8 wins except Dooley.
Balls I get it you don't like Franklin. I understand. Coaches for decades have been trying to lead Vandy over Ga, Fla and us. Now all the sudden they are playing a weak schedule, against teams with injuries and winning? There is a reason they are "learning to win". We can agree to disagree. Go Vols!!
Yes, I don't like him and his look at me egotistical ways. However, I didn't say he hasn't done a good job. I said that he has done what others should've been doing all along. Schedule four cupcakes in out of conference and line yourself up to win 2 SEC games and you're bowl eligible. He's been lucky in the last 2 years that he has gotten to avoid Bama and LSU and they have Ole Miss as their current West opponent. Now Ole Miss is respectable so that easy win is gone.
Their out of conference slate next year though is pretty embarrassing. Temple, UMASS, Charleston Southern and Old Dominion (who just lost 80-20 to UNC this week). I'd be embarrassed to play those four teams.
You can't just look at the win-loss record. Sometimes you have to dig deeper and see who they actually played and beat. Last year they got Mizzou when the starting QB got hurt in the 1st quarter. They then got a beat up UGA and Fla team this year along with a UT team with a true freshman QB making his 3rd start. I'd say they've gotten some pretty fortunate bounces. Their best win is against an UGA team this year where their own QB went down and their 2nd string QB lead them to a victory. It helped that UGA gifted them two turnovers in the 4th quarter off a dropped punt and the punter dropped a snap with both deep in their own territory. Vandy hasn't been getting those type of bounces for decades. They have for the last couple of years.
Vandy has always played cupcakes. Their OOC schedule regularly consists of a South Carolina FCS opponent then some combo of NW, Duke, WF, Navy and a Sun Belt/CUSA opponent.
And since when have opportune TO's become lucky? Vandy has one of the best TO margins in the SEC, when does that stop being luck and become them making plays?
Always played cupcakes? Didn't they do a home and home with Michigan a couple years ago? Also, you'll notice that Vandy dropped the series with Northwestern (originally billed as a rivalry between academic-oriented programs) once NW got competitive.
Vandy didn't always play cupcakes, but Franklin is taking advantage of having 4 built in wins. There's nothing wrong with that approach, but let's not pretend that having 4 guaranteed wins plus beating teams at their lowest points in history makes Franklin the next Saban.