Oh my bad, so Pearlophile, let us look:
2005-2006: #2 Seed, buzzer-beater away from losing to #15 Winthrop. Loses to #9 Wichita State in the second round.
2006-2007: #5 Seed, allows a pathetic LBS team to score 80+, Upsets a one dimensional Virginia team. Blows a 20+ point lead against Ohio State.
2007-2008: 31-5, #1 Ranking, #2 Seed. Plays pathetic with JP Prince at point against #15 American. Squeaks by Butler, fails to show up against Louisville.
2008-2009: #9 Seed, loses to Oklahoma State in first round.
2009-2010: #6 Seed, projected by many people to lose in first round.
Tell me Pearlophile hoops guru, what is so special about underachieving?