Here's why I'm "all in" with CJH.
The BYU game is the only loss of his 8 in his career that was by more than a single possession. That tells me that losses are typically because of in-game mistakes, not fundamental issues with scheme, game plan, or development of players. Something we've lacked since Kiffin was here.
Look at Kiffin's first year, Ole Miss game (which we wore in it until into the 3rd when Ole Miss' rushing attack wore out the defense) we got wrecked and he didn't coach the bowl game. But all the other losses (4 total) were by single possessions, because even a young Kiffin was developing our players, game planning well, and running a successful scheme. I think we'll see similar results from CJH, this first year will likely be a bit worse thought but once he's got the culture changed we should be a competitive team week to week winning more than we lose.