Coaching at what level? I agree about coaching issues at younger ages, but the national-level coaches are good. I think the breakdown in US soccer is multi-layered and centers around the sport as a money-making enterprise lacking any specific national goals/techniques. For example,
- Unlike some countries, US soccer does not try to instill any particular style of play across the board from the earliest ages. When you take kids to the national level, they are coming from across the country with a multitude of style differences. Unless these kids play together a lot, they will not be play cohesively. I would like to see more education from the national level instructing youth leagues and coaching clinics to drive a particular style. Do we want to play more physically like England, more efficiently and structured like Germany, the tiki-taka Spanish style, or more individually-skilled play like Brazil?
- The youth coaches, who are influencing kids from ages 3 to say select/club age, often lack the appropriate background and coaching experience to develop players. The knowledge and experience with the sport of many youth soccer coaches are far less than basketball, baseball, and football coaches. When this happens, the biggest, fastest, and strongest kids will dominate the games at the early ages, when a lot of the true skill and touch should be developed.
- Soccer in the US is too disjointed with too many leagues, academies, etc. My youngest child to go through the youth programs was in three different leagues with her club team as well as ODP (olympic development program) and her high school team. The US would benefit from a more strongly structured national level driving the organizations through the youth leagues. The proliferation of leagues has confused parents and resulted in leagues with watered-down talent. The youth systems have USSSA, AYSO, SAY, and USYSA among others setting rules and requirements.
- Club soccer in the DFW area typically costs in excess of $3,000 per year not counting uniforms (which may run $500), out-of-town tournaments, and position-specific training (keepers, for example). While scholarships do exist, the sport often loses good players due to the exorbitant cost. This cost was traditionally for the club-level players beginning at U11, but the introduction of the youth academy programs has now pushed higher costs to the younger ages.
- Soccer in the US lacks the unstructured play seen with other sports. For example, it is common to drive by a park and see kids playing basketball or football, but less common to see a bunch of kids playing soccer without coaches. This is one of the largest hindrances to soccer achievement in the US. When you visit Brazil, Argentina, Spain, etc., you will see young kids playing at the parks playing soccer. The skills and experience learned from the actual unstructured play are tremendous.
Sorry for the long response, but soccer is a sport that I have been involved in for a long time. I have coached/managed youth soccer for more than 20 years and been actively involved in leading youth leagues during that same time. With the talent we have in the US, there are no excuses for not dominating on the world stage.